News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Is their immutable backup provider?

Currently I am using a BlueRay device to have a immutable backup of my server. Each week after a back up I take a disk and put it in a vault.

This is a bit cumbersom process and also I like to have a real time backup.

I am looking for online service that can provide the same type of service. The only way some one can erase the backup is by not paying the bills.

Having access to online erase function is not acceptable as one of the eployees can go postal and erase the content.

Thoughts ?

( 2 comments | on HN )
Re:Is their immutable backup provider? by LinuxBender on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:21AM (#36573287)
- I like to have a real time backup.

- online erase function is not acceptable

- looking for online service

I think the combination of requirements somewhat paints you into a corner.

A traditional option would be a BlueRay robot that automates the backups and puts them in a container that gets picked up by an off-site storage company like IronMountain. Even that is not entirely foolproof against employees deleting data as anyone with the customer manifest could find your boxes and destroy them. So your robot would have to do daily backups and then you would need contracts with multiple off-site storage companies and then have some type of bond with them so that non-payment does not cause data loss right away.

Another option that meets your real time requirement would be multiple contracts with data-vaulting companies that will legally protect N+2 copies of your data spread across multiple regions. These companies charge a few left arms and a couple right legs every year.

A cheaper solution would be to install big servers with a few of your friends and family members that have high speed internet such as fiber and rsync the data to them and hope that whoever wants your data destroyed can't legally compel all of them at the same time and that you are not putting your friends and family members in harms way. This could also be done using multiple colocation data-centers and big servers with contracts in the names of different LLC's to avoid mapping the data back to you if the concern is that someone is trying to cancel you and your data.

Everything else that exists conflicts with at least one of your requirements in my opinion.

Re:Is their immutable backup provider? by jayonsoftware on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:14AM (#36611998)
Well I can live with out realtime but prefer some thing that runs every few hours.

My primary concern is some one else in the company erasing files by mistake or a hacker erasing / encrypting my files. Github is a perfect soltuion as the files are imutable ...but any one who has my user id / pw can go and erase.

Putting a server with a Verbatim Blu-ray Recordable in a remote data center and backing up to that. The only issue is the advance investment on a server and also the max capacity of 100GB.

Ideal service is some thing like Amazon S3 but the files cant be erased at all (The only way files can be erased is when I stop paying)