News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by iwwr on Friday March 02, 2012 @09:18AM (#3656634)
This is shaping into a battle cry of the IP rent seekers:

"[We fight against] foreign criminals selling counterfeit pharmaceuticals to Americans?"

second only to "think of the children" and "Save American Jobs Law".

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by bad_user on Friday March 02, 2012 @09:45AM (#3656716)
The other weekend I somehow ended up seeing "Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance 3D".

Worst movie I ever saw in my life, but watch it, because the Ghost Rider considers illegal downloads a sin (line from the movie, can't reproduce the exact quote).

Hollywood has been brain-washing people for years and we shouldn't underestimate their power of persuasion.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by jamesgeck0 on Friday March 02, 2012 @10:30AM (#3656880)
To be fair, many major religions consider illegal downloads a sin also. What with breaking the law and all.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by comicjk on Friday March 02, 2012 @10:42AM (#3656927)
Breaking the law is against someone's religion? Whose? I think the typical argument is by analogy to theft.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by redthrowaway on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:18AM (#3657104)
"Render unto Caesar that which is due Caesar", etc. Most religions stress adherence to the laws of the land, except where those laws conflict with the edicts of the religion.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by bad_user on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:41AM (#3657209)
As far as Christianity is concerned, that's a guideline, not a sin. Churches have been known to harbor and protect people that broke the law.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by jamesgeck0 on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:37PM (#3657724)
Biblically, obeying the authorities set over you is a command from God, not a guideline. Disobeying God is sin, so disobeying the law is sin. The exception is when this obedience conflicts with other commands from God.

Exactly where the line between respect for the law and conflict with God's commands lie is a favorite topic for Christian ethics debates, but probably not relevant to the linked article. ;)

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by zotz on Friday March 02, 2012 @02:27PM (#3657954)
> "Render unto Caesar that which is due Caesar", etc.

Not all Christians have the same interpretation. I was taught in Catholic school that this meant that everything is God's and nothing is Caesar's.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by redthrowaway on Friday March 02, 2012 @02:50PM (#3658058)
It appears you are correct. [1] I was always taught that it was Jesus' way of telling his followers to obey the earthly laws (pay yo' taxes) only inasmuch as they do not conflict with the laws of Heaven.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Render_unto_Caesar...#Modern_in...

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by zotz on Saturday March 03, 2012 @12:16AM (#3659457)
I was taught it in the context of Haggai, a book that would have been known by both Jesus and the Pharisees:

2:8 - "The silver is mine and the gold is mine, saith the Lord.

Great answer to a trick question.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by djcapelis on Friday March 02, 2012 @09:53AM (#3656739)
Where "counterfeit" usually means totally legit pharmaceuticals overseas that someone in the US didn't make money off of (or enough money off of).
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by raganwald on Friday March 02, 2012 @10:07AM (#3656789)
Up here in the Socialist Republic of Canada, the counterfeit drug criminals are so entrenched in power that when you fill a prescription, the pharmacist is required by law to offer you the counterfeit drug alongside the brand-name drug, usually at about 25% of the brand name drug’s price.

Worse, the spin-masters in power have taken control of the conversation, everyone in Canada calls them “generic” drugs, as if molecules and atoms were identical to each other and there’s no difference besides the logo stamped on the pill and the label glued on the bottle.

And we’re prisoners of the system, trapped in the endless nightmare of free health care.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by redthrowaway on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:06PM (#3657583)
>And we’re prisoners of the system, trapped in the endless nightmare of free health care.

As a fellow prisoner of Soviet Kanuckistan, I feel I must rebel against the Department of Truth and point out that we pay, dearly, for health care. Interestingly, however, we spend only slightly more than our free brethren to the south: 7% vs 6.7% GDP (this is only public, not private spending).

pdf warning: http://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2009/fin/F2...

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by SkyMarshal on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:15AM (#3657083)
Is the generic model enough to fund actual R&D for new medicine? Eg, if generic were legalized everywhere, including the US, and it undercut pharmaceuticals so much that they went out of business, would new drug development cease?

Not that I'm a fan of intellectual property, but I do recognize that there are a few areas where the upfront investment to produce the product is so massive, and copying the final product so easy, that it might make sense to guarantee the profits for a period of time.

Does the pro-generic side have any data or counterpoint to that?

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by jedberg on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:33AM (#3657172)
Back in the day before "big pharma", medical advances came out of Universities, many of them publicly funded. I think if the big pharma were cut off at the knees funding-wise, we'd see a resurgence in academic research.

Which I personally think is far better, because typically (not always of course) academics will share and collaborate, instead of being in walled gardens.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by SkyMarshal on Friday March 02, 2012 @07:41PM (#3658943)
Ah, thanks, didn't know that. I suspect that would be far better for another reason as well - less funding and brain power spent on Viagra and 'quality of life' drugs, and more on cancer, AIDS, and other major but perhaps less profitable epidemics.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by coreyrecvlohe on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:18PM (#3657633)
Exactly.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by bad_user on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:48AM (#3657236)
If medicine came from R&D sponsored by the government, I think we'd live in a better place.

That's because big-pharma companies love to focus on treatments, not on prevention and they also like to focus on controlling the disease instead of curring it.

Like in the case of allergic asthma, why treat a patient once when you can take money from him monthly?

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by yalurker on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:34PM (#3657713)
To play devil's advocate, the moment the government gets involved, so do politics.

Contraception and sexually transmitted diseases - will the religious right / moral majority voters turn against a representative who supports medical research for these?

What about diseases associated with lifestyle - smoking, alcohol, obesity. Will a parent group ask why X million is going to emphysema research when it could have gone to childhood cancer research instead? What about the anti-vaccine groups? Vegan/Vegetarian groups? Whatever other special interest group or political viewpoint?

I really don't want to see Bill O'Reilly or Rosie O'Donnell on tv expressing their outrage at why funding is going to curing the wrong diseases/disorders.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by kamjam on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:50AM (#3657250)
Why is it that a pharmaceutical company spends billions upon billions on R&D and only gets to patent it product for 20 years, but some poxy artist/record label gets paid royalty for a cajillion years.

There's something very wrong there...

I'm in 2 minds about the whole medicine patent thing. One the one hand, as you say, new medicines would not be developed but on the other hand the patents drive the prices so high that people in 3rd world countries cannot afford them. It also means medicines for 3rd world diseases are not worthwhile for the large pharmas. There really needs to be a better balance, maybe spending 5-10% of their R&D on medicines they know will never see it's return on investment but will save many more lives than their high profit products.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by jrockway on Friday March 02, 2012 @11:34AM (#3657177)
It will fund research, but not multi-billion dollar TV advertising campaigns.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by WildUtah on Friday March 02, 2012 @03:33PM (#3658242)
Generic medicines aren't available until the 20-year patent period runs out. Some of the profits from the patent period go to more research to make new drugs and obtain new patent rights. (Pharma is one of the exceptional few fields in which patents promote innovation instead of taking their usual role of blocking it.)

The additional profits that come from lobbying after year 20 to keep out generics don't get reinvested into more research, they get reinvested into more lobbying.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by raganwald on Friday March 02, 2012 @03:52PM (#3658315)
What makes the entire industry possible is that Canada only grants drug patent protection for five years, while America grants drug patent protection for twenty. Therefore, there’s a fifteen-year period during which Canadian companies can legally manufacture generic drugs that are illegal to import into the USA.

I suspect a lot of the talk about counterfeits and generics misses the third category, generics that are contraband in the USA because they are still under patent protection.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by meanguy on Friday March 02, 2012 @10:17AM (#3656830)
Counterfeit is different than generic: it was explicitly defined in Section 202 of SOPA as "falsely representing the source, manufacturer or distributor." As I wrote in a previous essay "You can still buy your overseas boner pills; they're just less likely to say Viagra on them."

The USDA can identify the source of bad pork; the FDA similarly needs to investigate bad batches of medicine.

Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by finnw on Friday March 02, 2012 @12:45PM (#3657494)
Interesting - that means if I manufacture & package my own pills, with my own logo, but print "contains Sildenafil" on the box when it doesn't, that does not qualify as counterfeiting?
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by meanguy on Friday March 02, 2012 @02:09PM (#3657878)
In that case, you'd likely be charged under a fraud statute (misrepresenting a product) versus counterfeiting (misrepresenting the source of a product). Selling a sugar pill isn't a trademark violation. Stamping Viagra on it is.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by william42 on Friday March 02, 2012 @10:07AM (#3656792)
I'm skeptical of the legitimacy of any business that advertises itself mostly through spam.
Re:RIAA CEO Hopes SOPA Protests Were a 'One-Time Thing' by djcapelis on Saturday March 03, 2012 @01:02AM (#3659517)
That's like saying you're skeptical of the Rolex business because "it advertises itself mostly through spam". Don't be silly, there are a number of vendors of pharmaceuticals online that are legitimate businesses, they are separate from the people who send you spam.

It seems you probably don't have a condition that would lead you to need to know about their services. I wish you continued good luck on that front.