You have to remember that NewsBlur is unlike any other reader. It shows the original site, it filters and highlights stories, and it's being actively developed. There is a huge swatch of sites for which using Twitter is no substitute. You just want to read every post from those Tumblrs. You don't want to miss what Gruber is saying on Daring Fireball. And Salt & Fat podcasts are only once a week. You sure you want to rely on catching that single tweet a week that gives the link?
As long as the technology is good, I think there's an enormous market, full of people struggling to keep up with a dozen blogs by having to manually visit them all every day.
I'm not going for the expert RSS readers who use RSS in a way I never did. I followed 40-some sites when I started building NewsBlur. I now follow around 110. I never used Google Reader, and I think there's a lot more people like me than the ones who were already hooked on RSS.
I'm a premium subscriber on NewsBlur and love it. I was never satisfied with a reader until NewsBlur came around.
My question, though, is that RSS usage seems to have plateaued, and may even be declining. Twitter, especially, has taken a fairly hard line in treating RSS as a second class citizen. Do you think there's a risk that other sites will move away from RSS in favor of social media, and, if so, do you have any plans to deal with that eventuality?