News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by cableshaft on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:17AM (#36536456)
I hope students and former students don’t forget this in 2024.

The establishment (and especially conservatives in power) don’t want you to have any relief and keep you from buying a home, having children, etc at a reasonable age.

I paid off my student loan debt but know plenty of people who are paying a lot and not even making a dent in their student loans after a decade or more of payments. Outrageous student loan debt is pretty much single-handedly creating a lost generation.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by tastyfreeze on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:27AM (#36536680)
The government should not be forgiving any debt taken on by anybody. The attempt to do so was blatantly buying votes.

You were responsible and paid off your debt. Taking on unsustainable debt is a choice. It was not forced on anybody. Why do you think that the government should absolve responsibility of other debt holders?

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by ssully on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:31AM (#36536771)
The government is constantly forgiving debts. What are you talking about?
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by lukas099 on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:43AM (#36537030)
Why do you assume parent isn't against the government forgiving debts those other times?
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by ohthatsnotright on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:30AM (#36536751)
Now let's do PPP loans.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by infamouscow on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:38AM (#36536944)
There are two distinct differences:

1. PPP loans came about because the government interfered with the economy, forcing businesses to close at gun point in many states.

2. PPP loans came about by an act of Congress. Congress controls the money, not the executive branch.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by ohthatsnotright on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:36PM (#36538034)
They are comparable, the number of PPP loans taken out and not used for the intended purpose is quite high, and there is massive fraud, yet those are forgiven. Everyone is arguing in circles on this or speaking past each other. The HEROES Act allowed for modifying loan terms. Regardless, PPP loans should not have been forgiven as they where without following the law Congress passed. So, now, let's do PPP loans.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by infamouscow on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:12PM (#36538607)
> They are comparable, the number of PPP loans taken out and not used for the intended purpose is quite high, and there is massive fraud, yet those are forgiven.

You're conflating forgiveness with fraud. The Small Business Administration, FBI, DoJ, and IRS are all investigating fraudulent loans.

> Everyone is arguing in circles on this or speaking past each other. The HEROES Act allowed for modifying loan terms.

The HEROES Act was passed by Congress. Congress can do whatever it wants with those tax dollars because they controls taxes, not the executive branch.

> Regardless, PPP loans should not have been forgiven as they where without following the law Congress passed. So, now, let's do PPP loans.

"Should not" is your opinion. And again, Congress can do whatever it wants with those tax dollars.

It seems like your position is Congress should do something about student loans, but lack a convincing argument to persuade the electorate to pressure Congress.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:34AM (#36536855)
> hope students and former students don’t forget this in 2024

To be fair, the Congress could have enabled this via statute during its Democrat-controlled phase. But it didn't, so a legally-dubious administrative fix was attempted. This issue is likely to be as spicy at the primary level as it will be in the general.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by monocasa on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:55AM (#36537264)
The broad authority was already approved by Congress in statute.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:31PM (#36537945)
> broad authority was already approved by Congress in statute

No, it wasn't, at least not clearly. The statute the Secretary of Education relied on is the HEROES Act of 2003, which lets them "waive or modify." It's a novel reading of that statute (and its intent) to say it permits large-scale forgiveness. (It's not textually inappropriate, hence the grey area.)

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by monocasa on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:52PM (#36538271)
I mean, waiving student loans is exactly the authority you've quoted there. Forgiveness is simply a synonym for fully exercising that provision in this case.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:56PM (#36538336)
> waiving student loans is exactly the authority you've quoted there

At the time the HEROES Act was passed, forgiveness was separately considered by the Education Act. (For example, "bankrupt borrowers may have their loans forgiven.") There is the added complication that it's not a straightforward waiver of statute, but, due to the income qualification, a writing of provisions anew.

Based on my reading, saying student loans will be automatically forgiven in bankruptcy as well as increasing the number of professions considered "public servants" seems the savvier way to go.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by monocasa on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:20PM (#36538739)
> At the time the HEROES Act was passed, forgiveness was separately considered by the Education Act. (For example, "bankrupt borrowers may have their loans forgiven.")

That separate bill adds other authorities but doesn't restrict the ability to waive or modify during a national emergency. The heroes act of 2003 makes no reference to bankruptcy. https://www.congress.gov/108/plaws/publ76/PLAW-108publ76.pdf

> There is the added complication that it's not a straightforward waiver of statute, but, due to the income qualification, a writing of provisions anew.

Waive and modify.

> Based on my reading, saying student loans will be automatically forgiven in bankruptcy as well as increasing the number of professions considered "public servants" seems the savvier way to go.

What test did you use to come to that being the limit of the powers here (or near)?

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:21PM (#36538766)
> What test did you use to come to that being the limit of the powers here (or near)?

Not limit. That’s safely within the scope the opinion finds.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by zeroonetwothree on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:14PM (#36540622)
It says "[the Secretary] may waive or modify any statutory or regulatory provision applicable to the student financial assistance programs under title IV of the [Education Act] as the Secretary deems necessary in connection with a war or other military operation or national emergency."

So "waive or modify" refers to a regulatory provision of the loans, not the loans themselves. This makes it far less convincing that Congress intended for the loans themselves to be waived.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by beej71 on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:29AM (#36536721)
I seem to recall that this affects something like 20 million student voters. And lots of them have swayable parent and sibling voters. If I were the Democrats, I'd definitely be leveraging the heck out of this decision next election.

Personally, I don't think forgiveness is worth much without structural changes behind it. It's just a one-off bailing effort while ignoring the gaping hole in the hull. Roll tuition back to 1980 levels (inflation adjusted), as well.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by lazycog512 on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:28AM (#36536701)
I don't think it's an unreasonable idea - we should rethink the role of higher education in society and/or provide aid to people that got tricked into taking out loans.

But this is a constitutional issue. It needs to be run by Congress.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by bdw5204 on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:33AM (#36536814)
What I don't understand is why the Republicans don't just respond by supporting student debt cancellation combined with a tax on university endowments. The obstinate "pay back your debts" position is such an obvious political loser for them that turns out voters against them and also prevents people from buying homes and having children (things that, statistically speaking, make people more conservative). Taxing the universities would solve the "it costs too much" problem and would tax an entity that conservatives see as an enemy. They could even combine it with the DeSantis campaign's proposal to make universities responsible for defaulted debt[0].

I think part of it is that the Republican Party is largely dominated by elderly people who aren't aware just how exorbitant the cost of college is these days because it wasn't when they were young. You don't see the same hostility to Biden's student debt relief proposal or obsession with tax cuts for the wealthy among younger Republicans whose concerns tend to be more about what's happening in the culture (the "parents rights" messaging clearly isn't targeted towards elderly conservatives who presumably don't have children in K-12 school).

[0]: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/campaigns/desantis-p...

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by Philorandroid on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:33AM (#36536816)
Fascinating. Can you cite a link from the Conservative Council of Evil Affairs website? I'm sure they've got "we're evil and hate you" in the mission statement somewhere.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by xhkkffbf on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:24AM (#36536616)
The debts are huge, but forgiving them is not the answer. If the debt is so toxic, why is the US government still creating new loans that are just as big or even larger? And why are the colleges still forcing their students into the same debt?

The right solution would be to halt the lending entirely.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by cableshaft on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:27AM (#36536684)
Why not both? Damage has already been done and hurt a bunch of people, but student loan reform is also needed.

Although not sure about halting it entirely. Imposing price limits on tuition and/or loans should be sufficient.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by bavell on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:55AM (#36537259)
We should do both. However, the Dem leadership are not interested in doing both, they only want the quick and easy win (which turned out to be neither).
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by beowulfey on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:31AM (#36536779)
That doesn't help the people who are already hurting by this though.

It's the same idea as the PPP loans -- for people who are struggling to make payments, this would have been incredibly helpful.

It's two separate issues.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by xhkkffbf on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:35AM (#36536879)
Helping the people who are hurting is profoundly unfair to the people who spent within their means. I know plenty of people who didn't go to a fancy college because they couldn't afford them. Mercy to the free spending debtors is also an insult to the careful ones who kept within their budget.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:28AM (#36536703)
The right solution in my opinion would be to nationalize the universities and end this predatory nonsense.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by tastyfreeze on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:43AM (#36537020)
I don't think stopping lending is the answer. Stopping government guaranteed loans and undischargable debt is a better answer. I have no issue with private lending.

The guaranteed loans skew the market. They are a big banner to schools saying the government will pay you with tax dollars if you can get the loan qualifying kids to register. And, that is exactly what they did.

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by nradov on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:13PM (#36537602)
Schools should have some skin in the game. If one of their former students defaults (regardless of whether they graduated or not) then the school should have to eat part of the cost. This would help to hold down tuition, and force them to be more responsible about admitting students who are unlikely to succeed.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by a_subsystem on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:19AM (#36536505)
When you make decisions, you should be responsible for the outcomes of those decisions.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by toomuchtodo on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:25AM (#36536627)
2 million folks (ie voters) over the age of 55 die every year, and 4 million young folks age into voting every year. I find it questionable if this idea can withstand the eventual tipping point when younger cohorts are tired of subsidizing the folks who pulled the ladder up behind them (housing, healthcare, wages that don't keep up and tenuous unemployment, requiring degrees that require debt with no assurance of a job after, safety nets that may be substantially impaired by the time they qualify for them). These young folks (top of Gen Z cohort is ~26 currently) are not why the national debt clock ticks where it does (~$32.25T as of this comment).

These geritocracy and conservative decisions will eventually catch up. As I tell my father, "be kind, I will be the one to pick your nursing home."

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by absrd on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:24AM (#36536622)
Unless you fall into protected categories such as "business owner" or "bank"
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by pianoben on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:25AM (#36536642)
Or, education should be free, full stop, and it should be okay to change things to make that true for as many people as possible.
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by malnourish on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:26AM (#36536648)
Is one way of taking responsibility not voting for people who will resolve a problem in exchange for taxes?
Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by welshwelsh on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:58AM (#36537317)
Is there actually a problem though?

Affordable education exists. You can get a bachelor's in Computer Science from WGU for a couple thousand. Georgia Tech offers an online MSCS for about $1k per month.

These programs are scalable and practical. They have such high capacities that they don't have to be selective, making them available to everyone. The cost is trivial compared to the potential earnings.

But for this type of education reform to work, people need to vote with their wallets for the most affordable option. That's only going to happen if they are held personally accountable for their education spending.

Why would somebody choose an affordable, practical program over a needlessly expensive program if the government is paying for it? Where is the incentive to minimize cost and maximize ROI?

Re:Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Forgiveness Plan by geraltofrivia on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:21AM (#36536556)
Yes indeed. Like would you like the heated pan or the actual fire? /s