News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Keeping Open Source Open by m4r71n on Thursday June 29, 2023 @07:06PM (#36528056)
> "Consequently, we now have to gather the source code from multiple sources, including CentOS Stream, pristine upstream packages, and RHEL SRPMs."

Oh no! How dare they make us do the work?

It feels tiring to hear these arguments that they must be provided with everything bundled neatly with no questions asked and no contributions to the actual upstreams.

Re:Keeping Open Source Open by djbusby on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:48PM (#36529030)
They arent asking to be handed everything - they've simply explained how the process has changed now.

Complaining about change; and describing the steps that are being taken is far from saying they "must be provided with everything bundled neatly with no questions asked"

Re:Keeping Open Source Open by nhanlon on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:56PM (#36529108)
Yeah, that's not what any of us are saying.

We already _do_ a lot of work. This is _more_ work.

Re:Keeping Open Source Open by notacoward on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:22PM (#36530144)
So who should be doing that work? On whose payroll? Should Red Hat engineers be spending their time de-branding and wrapping things up neatly for rebuilders to use? Note that every minute they spend on that is a minute they're not spending on adding features, fixing bugs, or backporting fixes to the last ten years' worth of releases. You know, the things they're actually obligated to do by their contracts with customers. Why should they continue letting free work for non-contractual partners - who seem increasingly inclined to be competitors - displace or delay that?

This is the rebuilders' burden, and always has been. It should be their engineers doing that work, just as with other open-source project. If you want to rebuild TensorFlow or React, slap on your own branding, sell support for it, do you think those teams will go out of their way to repackage stuff for your convenience? That's above and beyond common open-source practice. Expecting them to continue going above and beyond forever just seems awfully entitled.

Re:Keeping Open Source Open by toyg on Friday June 30, 2023 @06:33AM (#36532668)
Note that they're actually doing more work now (checking for contractual entitlements, playing whack-a-mole with rebuilders, trying to reassure ecosystem partners, etc etc) than they did before.
Re:Keeping Open Source Open by notacoward on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:12AM (#36536324)
I'm not sure that's true at all. Having done a bit of packaging myself, I'm well aware that it's hard, tedious, frustrating work. Doing it twice, once for their own users and again for the benefit of those whose only practical effect is to fragment the ecosystem, is a substantial burden.
Re:Keeping Open Source Open by mackca on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:27AM (#36536679)
> playing whack-a-mole with rebuilders Are they playing whack-a-mole? Or was this one change that people are arguing (and Red Hat's lawyers seem to think) is within their rights under the GPL ? It will be whack-a-mole if Red Hat tries to stop supporting VPS instances or stop updating UBI, both of a 1% chance of going away.
Re:Keeping Open Source Open by m4r71n on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:37AM (#36534660)
More work that has little effect on the actual upstream ecosystem beyond giving out something for free that 20k people at Red Hat are literally paid for. Ubuntu is not a clone of Debian, they extend it, tweak it, provide the code back to the community. What is the specific parts of the work that Rocky does that benefits the open-source community? What improvements has the community benefited from through your "work"?