News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Hacker News Deliver Value For Startups? by brudgers on Thursday March 01, 2012 @10:52AM (#3652560)
Irrespective of the relationship slideshare has to Ycombinator or HackerNews, the "buried" article simply didn't gain traction - it happens all the time.

200 visits is just a small slice of HN users and reflect a response to the title of the article, not the quality of the article itself.

Anecdote is not evidence, but the article wasn't compelling enough that I would be likely to upvote it - upvotes are the only thing that keeps new stories from being buried and flagging only comes into play once a recent story gets upvotes.

New articles get just one point all the time - indeed I've seen cases where a story had no votes or comments the first time it was posted only to make the front page and generate lively discussion when reposted later with a slightly different URL.

Odds are that any new article will be ignored. A conspiracy is not necessary - and since the article was buried by a lack of points and the weight of time, it's hard to believe that there was one.

Consider it editorial feedback in regards to style, timing and relevance.

Re:Does Hacker News Deliver Value For Startups? by pkenjora on Thursday March 01, 2012 @12:53PM (#3653147)
I appreciate the feedback. It was just surprising to see the article with significantly more relative traction get buried while others I've posted without seem to still be here.

I hopeI was fair in my analysis, given the data I had at hand. Still think its worth posting to Hacker News, just with a grain of sand.

I'm pragmatic, which is cool because if Hacker News is not what I said, its only a matter of time before I come around.