Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned
by marcosdumay on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:59PM
(#36525143)
> You've got to try to make things right.
Well, ok, you should.
Now, favoring person A due to their skin color, at the expense at person X, because person B was once harmed to favor person Y due to their skin color does not strike me as a productive way to do that.
You can start to make things right by banning that shit about children of alumni, all the bullshit police behavior there, doing some real wealth redistribution, etc. You can go looking at individuals that were harmed too, but modern legal systems have a really hard time dealing with that kind of situation, so be prepared to cover new ground, and be wary of not creating larger injustices than the ones you are trying to fix.
Anyway, I'm far from the US too. The entire thing isn't completely academic to me, but it's close to that.
Well, ok, you should.
Now, favoring person A due to their skin color, at the expense at person X, because person B was once harmed to favor person Y due to their skin color does not strike me as a productive way to do that.
You can start to make things right by banning that shit about children of alumni, all the bullshit police behavior there, doing some real wealth redistribution, etc. You can go looking at individuals that were harmed too, but modern legal systems have a really hard time dealing with that kind of situation, so be prepared to cover new ground, and be wary of not creating larger injustices than the ones you are trying to fix.
Anyway, I'm far from the US too. The entire thing isn't completely academic to me, but it's close to that.