News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by jupp0r on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:15AM (#36521510)
I would like to point out that any discrimination based on race (and thus affirmative action) is forbidden by law in lots of other countries, for example Germany.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by b0sk on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:24AM (#36521669)
I mean, in a vacuum, it makes no sense but in this case, I agree with KBJ's dissent. In a country with a historical baggage like US, something like this is needed.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by sp527 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:14PM (#36522457)
Plenty of other identity groups have suffered heavy discrimination across US history (Irish, Italians, Japanese, Jews, to name a few). They don't seem to require a policy like affirmative action to ensure they obtain a fair proportion of seats at top universities. Plenty of highly impoverished immigrants arrive in the US and have children that academically outperform the kids of very privileged parents.

What's needed is not affirmative action but a more honest appraisal about what the real obstacles are for Black and Hispanic students. And perhaps we'll discover that those obstacles cannot in fact be legislated out of existence.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by prottog on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:21PM (#36522567)
> a more honest appraisal about what the real obstacles are for Black and Hispanic students

Different cultural and ethnic groups value different things. Virtually nobody who clamors for more black and Hispanic representation in Harvard's undergrad class, for example, also clamors for more Asian representation in the NFL, even though that disparity is much, much greater, with only a single-digit number of current players.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by LorenPechtel on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:57PM (#36523219)
Affirmative action is basically robbing Peter to pay Paul. The beneficiaries weren't discriminated against, the people losing out weren't discriminators.

There is a problem--but it's a matter of why they aren't as qualified. Pretending they are isn't going to fix the actual problem.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by bodhi_mind on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:43PM (#36523916)
I understand your perspective, but it's essential to consider the historical context and systemic impact of discriminatory practices such as redlining. While affirmative action aims to address the long-standing inequalities faced by marginalized communities, it's not about "robbing Peter to pay Paul."

Redlining, a discriminatory practice prevalent in the mid-1900s, systematically denied access to housing loans and opportunities to minority communities based on race. As a result, neighborhoods predominantly inhabited by minorities were deprived of investment, economic growth, and wealth accumulation. This created a cycle of limited opportunities and limited access to resources that persists today.

Over time, this has led to a significant wealth gap between racial groups. Affirmative action seeks to address this imbalance by providing opportunities for marginalized individuals to overcome historical disadvantages and achieve upward mobility.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by bitcurious on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:04PM (#36524314)
“The proof is in the pudding” if we’re sticking with idioms. Where the evidence of systemic racism is a lack of wealth, discriminate on wealth. Where the evidence is family structure, discriminate on family structure. Address disadvantage by addressing disadvantage, not by a racial proxy.

In programmer terms, racial affirmative action is a very lossy hash of reality, which leaves a lot of room for injustice both in terms of who it helps and who it doesn’t.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by pfannkuchen on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:01PM (#36525910)
> Redlining

As an aside, I’ve always been confused about the dynamics of redlining. Wouldn’t refusing to give any mortgages for a neighborhood reduce the cost of buying a house there? Is the idea that it was purchased by landlords and everyone was made to rent instead of buying? Lowering housing costs for a group generally doesn’t seem like a bad thing…

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by LorenPechtel on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:48PM (#36538209)
You're explaining why it came about, not why it's not an evil.

As for redlining--while it certainly existed in the past I noticed something when there was a flap about it a while back. There was a very detailed article in the local newspaper about local "redlining". However, it didn't make sense--why would bankers only discriminate against black neighborhoods with low-down mortgages? If black is relevant why not all mortgages?

How about a simpler explanation that fits the facts? Something stood out to me about their map--the map of the "redlined" zip codes exactly matched an earlier article about appreciation. Suppose the bankers are looking at the chance a house ends up underwater a few years down the road? That gives no inconvenient inconsistencies in their behavior. Yes, it hurt the neighborhood but there's no racism involved, just simple economics.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by jupp0r on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:59PM (#36524216)
The assumption that Germany has no historical baggage is pretty bold.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by raxxorraxor on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:33AM (#36530890)
Yes, but Germany currently also discriminates against formerly discriminated groups.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by Kranar on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:07PM (#36522349)
This is simply untrue and you are unlikely to find any country that has such absolute policies codified in their law.

The example you give, Germany, has its own form of affirmative action codified under the Allgemeines Gleichbehandlungsgesetz which permits employers to give preferential treatment to ethnic groups subject to structural disadvantages or underrepresentation. Germany uses the term "Positive Action" in their legislation:

http://www.ilo.org/dyn/natlex/docs/ELECTRONIC/77201/93329/F6...

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by jupp0r on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:10PM (#36524415)
Your rebuttal is simply not true.

Article 3 of the German constitution (Grundgesetz):

"No person shall be favoured or disfavoured because of sex, parentage, race, language, homeland and origin, faith or religious or political opinions. No person shall be disfavoured because of disability."

https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_gg/englisch_gg.h...

Job ads in Germany often state that disabled applicants will be favored because this is explicitly allowed.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by NoRelToEmber on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:11PM (#36524430)
> Germany uses the term "Positive Action"

Interesting how they never call it "racial discrimination" when it's something they like. I guess they had to come up with a euphemism to avoid the Pavlovian response they instilled.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court curbs affirmative action in university... by raxxorraxor on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:30AM (#36530867)
It is also called positive discrimination if you translate directly, which I believe is an oxymoron and I believe it should be revised as well for modern times.