Re:Cooklang – Recipe Markup Language
by tharkun__ on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @06:12PM
(#36513371)
That isn't what I said though. Like my sibling mentions, of course you mention the ingredient. But you don't list the ingredient at the front as "2 cups of butter, melted" etc. and then in the text you say it again "Mix the two cups of melted butter with the 4 cups of sifted wheat flower...". You use short references and that's it.
The point of cooklang seems to want to be to read well as plaintext though. Like markdown promises. But cooklang does not seem to succeed in that. I find the embedded ingredient with quantity markup destroys my reading flow and doesn't allow me to use the plaintext to actually use the recipe. I have to use the compiler. In markdown I find the plaintext is all I usually need/use and I never compile it to a nice looking document, except if I am trying to publish it for someone else.
YMMV. I don't have many such recipes and the few that do work very well in plain English.
It seems like you're saying that writing a recipe is done more often than reading it. I would question that very much unless you're someone that is like a professional recipe maker.
See above on markdown. I primarily read my `README.md` et. al. in `vi`, not through generated HTML in a browser. YMMV as always.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There are no comments on this comment yet.