News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by jiggy2011 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @10:38PM (#3650809)
Depends on how long people are willing to postpone. If you have a choice between seeing a movie today for $x or waiting a couple of years and seeing it for free and legally, what would you take?

The legal part is important , because there would be a good business model in simply taking all of the copyright expired works and creating a download/streaming website for it all and charging basically for the bandwidth and easy UI, not to mention that every TV manufacturer would want to integrate this.

That would be a massive library of stuff, far more than you could watch or listen to in your lifetime, would you really be worried about seeing the newest blockbuster the day it came out?

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by jacktoole1 on Thursday March 01, 2012 @01:56AM (#3651237)
Based on the comments on the iBooks DRM thread, mass media has a very small tail: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3633839

I think a lot of people want to keep up with the latest media, and there are lots of social reasons to do so. The latest TV shows, movies, and books will be the ones your friends are watching/reading. As xkcd eloquently put it: http://xkcd.com/606/

This points out one more factor: content prices decrease dramatically after several years. Videogames go from $60 to $10 on Steam; Movies end up in discount bins; books end up cheap on amazon or from used bookstores.

Books are an interesting example: when they are first published it is difficult to acquire them at a local library (because lots of other people want to read the same new book), but after some time (usually much less than a year), they are easily acquirable for free. If the library model works, such that authors are satisfied with the profitability of writing books, then reducing copyright term to a few years is probably reasonable.

EDIT: I personally think somewhere around 10 years is probably more reasonable, but I think the discussion around a more extreme 2-5 years is interesting, and the current term length is ridiculous.

Re:Why wait? How Congress could fix copyright now by epscylonb on Thursday March 01, 2012 @03:23AM (#3651387)
I think 5 years.

I suspect the business model that is most likely to work is an extension of the current one.

Larger multiplexes with more screens, when you go to the cinema you have a wide choice of movies to see.

Movies would no longer drop out of the cinema within a week or two.

In this controlled environment it is easier for the cinemas to prevent copying.

Only after a long cinema run would the film be released on DVD, after which point the copyright expires and you can copy to your hearts content.

I can even see this business model perhaps working for music as well.