News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by speakspokespok on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:19PM (#36501070)
I've always heard ACH is slow, and the article mentions that Venmo uses it. So why then can I deposit my Venmo balance into my linked bank account almost instantly for a very small fee?
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by darkerside on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:22PM (#36501098)
Because Venmo is willing to float you the money despite the risk it might not go through
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by pbreit on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:45PM (#36501261)
Few understand that the movement of money and information about the movement of money happen on different schedules.
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:59PM (#36501370)
In ACH, they generally happen together, and with at least a few hours of delay. That's why instant generally usually doesn't use it.
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by pbreit on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @02:51AM (#36503211)
They absolutely do not. That’s the whole point.
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:52AM (#36505677)
Could you maybe elaborate instead of just disagreeing without references or even explanation?

In ACH, as soon as you get the notification about an inbound credit transfer, it's effectively final. Whether it ultimately settles on the same day or 1-2 days later is irrelevant, since what matters is finality.

ACH credit transfer clawbacks are very rare compared to ACH debit rejections (due to e.g. insufficient funds or fraud).

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by pbreit on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:55PM (#36514446)
Some recipients might consider a valid initiation sufficient to fulfill. Others may way for settlement. Some may wait longer to see if there's a return. And then posting times and amounts can vary quite a bit.
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by rodgerd on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:51PM (#36501313)
Banking is an eventually consistent system.

People outside banks often find this surprising.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @10:01PM (#36501389)
How can Venmo be the one floating anything in GPs scenario when they are the sending entity? If anything, it's the receiving bank that would have to bear the risk of the payment never arriving after being notified about it out-of-band, somehow.

There's no such mechanism that I'm aware of, though – instead instant deposits usually use debit card rails.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by scrollaway on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @05:12AM (#36504110)
Venmo is sending money from Venmo bank accounts to your bank, through a direct integration.

The receiving bank doesn’t bear any risk, Venmo is taking the risk.

You are the person who is the beneficiary on the accounts this money sits on. So you are responsible for it. If an entity sends money on your behalf, they take the responsibility for the money you send. That means they are the ones with the processes that will trigger if money doesn’t clear as expected. Processes which may involve anything from reminder emails and push notifications, all the way to debt recovery companies, lawyers and thugs showing up at your door.

Both entities have float. The question is who is taking legal risk.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:50AM (#36505657)
> The receiving bank doesn’t bear any risk, Venmo is taking the risk.

What risk? Venmo is the sender here. Almost by definition, the sender doesn't have any risk: They either send money they have (in which case all is well), or promise to send money they don't have (which is the recipient's problem).

If you're talking about the transaction that originally funded the to-be-paid-out balance, that's a completely different story.

> Venmo is sending money from Venmo bank accounts to your bank, through a direct integration.

Yes, and that "direct" integration is typically ACH (for transfers "in 3-5 days") or debit card rails (for "instant payouts"). It might also be RTP these days, and maybe soon will be FedNow, which are both cheaper than debit card push payments (although I don't see payment app providers stopping their very lucrative business of charging ~1% for instant payouts any time soon).

For ACH, there is no risk to the recipient. since nobody is floating anything: It takes 3-5 days. For debit cards, there is also no risk since these payments are effectively final immediately after they're announced to the recipient, even though they don't settle instantly.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by scrollaway on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:06AM (#36507542)
> They either send money they have (in which case all is well), or promise to send money they don't have (which is the recipient's problem).

No, they have the money. But the money is ultimately that of the Venmo user. If that money gets removed from the account by some other means (eg some form of clawback, dispute, whatever) then they're out that user's money, and they're on the hook: So Venmo pays for the user.

Every dollar is somebody else's dollar.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @02:53PM (#36510861)
> But the money is ultimately that of the Venmo user.

Sure, but that's completely independent of the finality, settlement timing, payment rails etc. of the payout side.

So if you're talking about the funding side, ACH is indeed very risky, since it's ACH direct debit. But great-GP was talking about Venmo payouts. There, Venmo is an ACH credit sender, which is risk-free.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by pests on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @11:26PM (#36501891)
They don't mean Venmo-to-Venmo rather Venmo-to-Bank.

A lot of apps like CashApp, Venmo, Uber Driver, Lyft Driver, etc give you two options for getting your money out of their app. Instant and Delayed. Delayed is usually free and deposits into a linked bank via ACH. Instant is immediate and is a reverse transaction on a linked debit card.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by jqpabc123 on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @12:22AM (#36502263)
Instant is immediate and is a reverse transaction on a linked debit card.

This is RTP and it usually isn't free.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:57PM (#36501353)
Instant deposits usually don't use ACH, but rather debit network rails. These are instant (at least the payment confirmation is, if not the settlement – but that's usually good enough for the use case.

If you can really perform one using your account and routing number, it might also be RTP.

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by westurner on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @04:39AM (#36503888)
From "FedNow FAQ" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32515531 :

> W3C ILP Interledger Protocol [1] specifies addresses [2]: [...]

>> Neighborhoods are leading segments with no specific meaning, whose purpose is to help route to the right area. At this time, there is no official list of neighborhoods, but the following list of examples should illustrate what might constitute a neighborhood:

>> - crypto. for ledgers related to decentralized crypto-currencies such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, or XRP.

>> - sepa. for ledgers in the Single Euro Payments Area.

>> - dev. for Interledger Protocol development and early adopters

> From "ILP Addresses - v2.0.0" [2]:

>> Example Global Allocation Scheme Addresses

>> - g.acme.bob - a destination address to the account "bob" held with the connector "acme"

>> - g.us-fed.ach.0.acmebank.swx0a0.acmecorp.sales.199.~ipr.cdfa5e16-e759-4ba3-88f6-8b9dc83c1868.2 - destination address for a particular invoice, which can break down as follows:

>> -- Neighborhoods: us-fed., ach., 0.

>> -- Account identifiers: acmebank., swx0a0., acmecorp., sales, 199 (An ACME Corp sales account at ACME Bank)

>> -- Interactions: ~ipr, cdfa5e16-e759-4ba3-88f6-8b9dc83c1868, 2*

> And from [3] "Payment Pointers and Payment Setup Protocols":

>> The following payment pointers resolve to the specified endpoint URLS:

  $example.com ->                https://example.com/.well-known/pay
  $example.com/invoices/12345 -> https://example.com/invoices/12345
  $bob.example.com ->            https://bob.example.com/.well-known/pay
  $example.com/bob -> https://example.com/bob
> The WebMonetization spec [4] and docs [5] specifies the `monetization` <meta> tag for indicating where supporting browsers can send payments and micropayments:

  <meta
  name="monetization"
  content="$wallet.example.com/alice">
ILP also specifies settlement; From "Fed expects to launch long-awaited Faster Payments System by 2023" (2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32658402 :

> And then you realize you're sharing payment address information over a different but comparably-unsecured channel in a non-stanfardized way; From https://github.com/interledger/rfcs/blob/master/0009-simple-... :

>> Relation to Other Protocols: SPSP is used for exchanging connection information before an ILP payment or data transfer is initiated*

> To do a complete business process, [there's] signaling around transactions, which then necessarily depend upon another - hopefully also cryptographically-secured and HA Highly Available - information system with API version(s) and database schema(s) unless there's something like Interledger SPSP Simple Payment Setup Protocol and Payment Pointers [...]

Clearing (finance) > US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clearing_(finance)#United_Stat...

ACH Network: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACH_Network :

> The Federal Reserve's FedACH and The Clearing House Payments Company's Electronic Payments Network (EPN) are the two ACH operators in the United States.[3]

From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28232243 :

> FWIU, each trusted ACH (US 'Direct Deposit') party has a (one) GPG key that they use to sign transaction documents sent over now (S)FTP on scout's honor - on behalf of all of their customers' accounts.

> *

Payment rail: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payment_rail

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by lxgr on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:54AM (#36505708)
Who/what are you replying to?
Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by westurner on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:13PM (#36522442)
What is ACH? What are "payment rails"? What can't we all just use EFT? Why are they satisfied and complacent with what we have?

Why do we have such a slow, fragmented, unsecured system(s) for banking and finance?

What are the solutions; how do we unify and eliminate waste?

Re:Anatomy of an ACH Transaction by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @10:13PM (#36501484)
That's how Zelle works. It's just a front end to ACH with delayed reconciliation while creating the appearance of instant transfers.