News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pretty Lisp by Arelius on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @04:43PM (#3649842)
What kind of work do you do? Moving the work from what language? Do you not worry about having to pay huge licensing fees to run your code elsewhere?
Re:Pretty Lisp by spitfire on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @06:38PM (#3650279)
Executive brief - Go high end, where the money is. Where results are valued.

Licensing isn't an issue - $3K/year+libraries for development. A runtime player for Mathematica costs $300. You just have to pick your projects carefully - No rails todo apps.

One recent project I worked on was auto segmentation and labelling of MRI images. Auto-segmentation was the easy part. Labelling however took several different approaches before I got something that works reliably.

Re:Pretty Lisp by Arelius on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @09:44PM (#3650700)
This sounds like the kind of work that most people I know would choose matlab for (image segmentation). I personally have never used either for such, but do you have any thoughts on the matter? Is Mathematica getting better at the things matlab used to be best at?
Re:Pretty Lisp by spitfire on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:16PM (#3650886)
It sort of comes down to what you're comfortable with. In this case, the strict image analysis parts were more minor compared to the real work. Also, Matlab seems to be stagnating, while Mathematica has been growing by leaps and bounds. Also, matlab doesn't have built in functionality for gui building, afaik.

A lot of my other work is much less suited to matlab. Mathematica is certainly much better for multi-domain work, which matlab barely supports.

Re:Pretty Lisp by taliesinb on Friday March 02, 2012 @01:03AM (#3655564)
I think most people you are know are just ignorant of how much better Mathematica is. It's okay. People like to stick to what they know.
Re:Pretty Lisp by Arelius on Saturday March 03, 2012 @03:06PM (#3660987)
Being more of a software engineer than a mathematician, and having no MatLab experience, and more basic Mathematica experience. That is, in fact, the the impression that I get. But I still see people using MatLab what seems like more often, and have no weight to backup my claim. I suppose I could learn both and do research, but in general, that seems so less important than getting actual work done.

One aspect that seems to be brought up about MatLab often is the community, it's often claimed, especially in the co punter vision world, that if an algorithm exists, it has an available implementation in MatLab source. Which seems significant.