Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by naner on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @09:01PM
(#3650636)
Perhaps they don't want others to hide their improvements and simply released the code to foster learning and collaboration. Id software uses GPL for their game engine releases as well. So I'm sure they both have their reasons.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by midnight_city on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @09:26PM
(#3650672)
From Cryptose's README.md:
License
-------
This game is licensed under the GNU General Public License (see gpl.txt). As the copyright owner, I hereby give anyone permission to re-license my GPL code under a non-GPL license for the purpose of distributing it in the iOS App Store or the Android Market.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by sanxiyn on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:50PM
(#3650965)
This is not what you think it is. This is necessary because GPL is incompatible with App Store. (It doesn't seem to be rigorously enforced, but search for "GNU Go App Store".)
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by rsynnott on Thursday March 01, 2012 @06:52AM
(#3651761)
Go was GPLv3, which is clearly incompatible with the App Store ToS. The situation with GPLv2 is considerably more ambiguous.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by rflrob on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @05:59PM
(#3650150)
> Insurgent Games only open sourced once they gave up, so they clearly know that open sourcing all your code is not a good idea when you're selling games.
To be a bit pedantic, all you can really say is that they didn't know whether open sourcing your code is a good idea when you're selling games. I could imagine myself being convinced that having open sourced a game makes you no more or less likely to lose market share to copycats than keeping it closed. I don't know that anyone's tried it, nor that there's a particularly good experiment one could do to test that.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by wtracy on Thursday March 01, 2012 @01:45AM
(#3651212)
"All the repositories are GPL'd, so I'm assuming they meant build in a purely educational setting."
Um, how about in a hobbyist setting?
Only a small subset of the people who write games are going to make money doing so. Many of them know this and do it just because they enjoy it. (See: Almost any mod community.)
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by Avshalom on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @10:50PM
(#3650837)
Actually games are almost completely unaffected by open sourcing the code. The value in 99% of games is in the level design/art/music assets which can be kept proprietary. It even maintains the spirit of the Four Freedoms.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by stephth on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @06:28PM
(#3650253)
Does anyone believe being selective about what you open source is a bad idea? If so could you share your perspective? (I'm asking as I'm guessing that may be why I got voted down)
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by nzmsv on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @06:45PM
(#3650303)
I think the answer, as usual, is "it depends". It can be bad when the open-source portion relies heavily on the closed-source components to function properly. One example: when Linksys was required to release their Linux-based router firmware, the wireless driver stayed closed-source. This effectively forced the use of 2.4 kernels for years, until a suitable substitute was developed. This exact situation is happening with Android: building a functional version for real hardware requires a large number of closed-source components, and they are a pain.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by windsurfer on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @07:39PM
(#3650446)
One of the developers moved on to the EFF, so it makes sense to make their code GPL.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by daeken on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @08:09PM
(#3650520)
How does that follow? The EFF doesn't promote the GPL, but rather open source software in general. I think you're mixing them up with the FSF.
Re:Insurgent Games Makes All Games Free, Releases Everything...
by windsurfer on Thursday March 01, 2012 @12:22AM
(#3651038)
Ah, I was under the impression that the EFF preferred the GPL, and primarily enforced the GPL. My mistake.
All the repositories are GPL'd, so I'm assuming they meant build in a purely educational setting.
It's a nice move, but why not go all the way and let developers leverage your code in their proprietary code? Insurgent Games only open sourced once they gave up, so they clearly know that open sourcing all your code is not a good idea when you're selling games.