Re:Google TV is still a flop
by ajross on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:07PM
(#3648598)
I think you have this backwards. What do people want then? I mean, my TiVo is getting old and it's time to look for a replacement. I'm looking around the field and as you point out, they're all pretty much the same. I want OTA TV capture and a reasonable interface to streaming content (currently using Netflix, but I'd be happy to jump ship).
It's a commodity market. No one cares about the UI[1], they want the content. So while I certainly agree that Google isn't going to get a huge win on this, they will certainly be a player.
[1] Though it has to not suck. I'd be very suspicious of a streaming app packaged with my TV. Google has a rather better track record of producing solid consumer software than, ahem, Vizio.
Re:Google TV is still a flop
by herval on Saturday March 03, 2012 @11:51AM
(#3660431)
IMHO, the UI will play a huge role in whichever solution comes out and dominates the market. TVs are everywhere, yet most users find them hard to deal with (even switching inputs is "hard", let alone doing stuff such as recording content)...
It's a commodity market. No one cares about the UI[1], they want the content. So while I certainly agree that Google isn't going to get a huge win on this, they will certainly be a player.
[1] Though it has to not suck. I'd be very suspicious of a streaming app packaged with my TV. Google has a rather better track record of producing solid consumer software than, ahem, Vizio.