The fact that a candidate loves problem solving / coding so much that they'd do it for fun is a pretty strong signal.
Like I said, it would take more effort from the interviewers to dig into.
But it would also provide more valuable feedback and result in better hires.
1. Many (most) engineers are not in positions to be able to meaningfully contribute to OSS (e.g. all the code I write for work is proprietary).
2. It can easily be faked.
3. Personal projects can sometimes be interesting, but often don't showcase usefulness (unless front-end).
4. Many high quality engineers don't like to spend their free time doing more of their job.
Some repos, of course, are more impactful though. And I would probably say that if you are someone who loves to write code 16 hours a day, more power to you, you deserve to be hired! But many quality engineers would get missed if that is the desired bar (which is fine - other companies will just scoop them up).
(edit: OSS engineers extra upset by what I'm saying, but there is a lot more to this world than just what shows up in your GitHub feed)