What you're proposing is actually not a ban on HFT, it's a ban on investment strategies other than value investing. How would you implement that in practice? Have every investor swear under oath that they do believe in the company's inherent value, regardless of the rest of the market's behavior?
> HFT goes against the original ethos of a market open to all.
What "original ethos" is that? And even if it existed, wouldn't excluding certain investors go against it much more?
And for the how, just limit the number of transactions one can do per second or the money one can exchange per second. Then everyone will have to be smart instead of being the one with the best connection. Or split the markets in "Joe invests" market and "Bigcorp" invests.
Whatever scheme is defined as "stock exchange" can surely be fixed by another scheme. Humans have been inventing games and agreed to rules for centuries, it's not like it's something we can't do.