Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by paulsutter on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:55PM
(#36485723)
do you have a link, love to learn how it worked out in other places
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by gnopgnip on Monday June 26, 2023 @06:43PM
(#36486858)
https://www.bnymellon.com/content/dam/bnymellon/documents/pd... has a good review of several countries laws
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by robertlagrant on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:18PM
(#36485990)
What's rent-seeking HFT?
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by lucubratory on Monday June 26, 2023 @06:05PM
(#36486524)
I'm not that person, but presumably it's that someone has purchased real estate in a geographically relevant location and constructed property on it/between it and the exchange which gives them an insurmountable latency advantage in HFT, and they are characterising the raking in of cash from that latency advantage as rent seeking.
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by gnopgnip on Monday June 26, 2023 @06:16PM
(#36486611)
Rent-seeking is an "economic activity to gain wealth without any reciprocal contribution of productivity". Or put another way it means societies resources are put towards wealth transfer instead of productivity/wealth creation.
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by robertlagrant on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @01:57AM
(#36489365)
Thank you; understood. I've just looked at the Wikipedia definition[0] as well, which is a little different, but I get the point you're making.
I haven't thought about this enough, but one thing I'd note is that HFT is risk-taking, and taking a risk generally has the possibility of profit or loss.
A second thing would be that the phrase "society's resources" is a bit dangerous, as it might let us think that the money they're using is somehow everyone's money. When in fact they're spending their money on this, hoping to make a profit.
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by nerdponx on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @04:24AM
(#36490306)
"Excess rent" is economics jargon for something akin to "selling something for more than its fair value". The idea with "rent-seeking" is therefore that of seeking opportunities to take advantage of or even create market distortions that work in your favor, allowing you to capture a greater share of surplus value than you would otherwise obtain in a theoretically-fair market.
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by robertlagrant on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:15AM
(#36491001)
How do HFT firms create market distortions that work in their favour?
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by nerdponx on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @06:50AM
(#36491208)
I'm not making the assertion, I am just trying to clarify the terminology.
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by gnopgnip on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @01:28PM
(#36496058)
>A second thing would be that the phrase "society's resources" is a bit dangerous, as it might let us think that the money they're using is somehow everyone's money. When in fact they're spending their money on this, hoping to make a profit.
From the perspective of the whole economy it is everyone's money. Rent seeking behavior is a dead weight loss due to market inefficiency. Through tax policy the incentives can change and largely remove this inefficiency.
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by karkari on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:23PM
(#36486059)
Is the $50b/year figure estimated after assuming the 'unproductive and rent seeking' HFT volume is eliminated?
Re:Lasers enable satellite internet backbone, might remove n...
by gnopgnip on Monday June 26, 2023 @06:26PM
(#36486703)
Yes, that estimate is with the greatly reduced HFT volume. And it may not be 100% accurate, HFT and trading in general could move to another market without these taxes and/or switch to a type of derivative with a lower/no tax. Like the UK, for swaps. But these other markets are smaller and not really a replacement. And these other markets may pass similar taxes in the future.
Hong Kong has an FTT of 0.13% currently, it was 0.1% from 1993-2021 so you can compare HFT impacts on these markets. Or compare dozens of other countries with similar rates, Switzerland, Taiwan, France, Italy, Japan.