News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by jcr on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @11:49PM (#3646494)
Some people just want to watch the world burn, but worse yet, some people want to watch the world burn while they merrily sing campfire songs and gleefully roast marshmallows.

The toughest thing to admit is the seemingly insane desires of both of these groups of people exist in everyone.

The reason why link-bait works -- even here on HN -- is simply the human propensity for an emotional response involving pitchforks and torches, either metaphorical or entirely real.

If you think back to the last time you were fired up about something, can you admit to being one of those people in the first paragraph above?

Whether you can admit it or not, you were one those "Burn it," folks. Sure, maybe you were slightly more diplomatic in your choice of words, such as saying "Stop it," or "Please stop," or even "Please consider the alternatives," or "Please be reasonable," but mincing words is just masking your opposition with pleasantries.

At one time or another, and to some degree absolutely everyone is one of the "burn it" folks. The world is full of annoying "flaws" to wear down your patience and tolerance until you oppose them in more actively.

Rather than derailing the conversation by picking an technical flame-bait example of a well contested hotspot known to evoke nerd-rage of the highest order, I'm going to play it safe, and reference the Dr. Seuss story, "Horton Heads a Who." Absolutely everyone has been one of the folks chanting "Boil That Dust Spec!"

Every programmer here can think of a "Spec" that they want to boil. ;)

Since everyone is guilty of being the opposition of something and wanting to tear down, disrupt, or change the status quo or situation in some way, you should be able to see how everyone is vying for the same prize, control. To put it more succinctly, everyone wants to be the authority in control.

In other words, many authorities are anti-authoritarians. Their refusals to cede control is their method to gain and retain control. Similarly, those who abide by existing authorities are merely employing a more deceptive method to gain and retain control. The hoop-jumpers and ladder-climbers are no different than their rebellious "anti-authoritarian" counterparts, save for the fact that the two groups are in constant competition due to the fact that the success of one is always detrimental to the goals of the other.

The most interesting exercise is to think about what things would be like if the situation was reversed; "Since you got a four year degree from a university, you obviously need to be chemically lobotomized with medications to treat your hoop-jumping disorder." Additionally, your diagnosis and prescription were written by a self-educated rebel, and ironically, being cured occurs when you refuse to take your meds.

There are no comments on this comment yet.