Hardly. Valve has been doing this with Steam for years. Microsoft does it with Xbox Live. It's the main caveat of a managed environment, sometimes the manager makes the wrong decisions.
This might be bad or distasteful, but it's not novel or unique. It's par for the course when it comes to software distributed through a central DRM system.
> Does Android require a Google account to use the market and get updates? Even if, you still can get an anonymous one.
You can do that with iOS too. Likewise, If Google decides to revoke your access to your Gmail account that all your Android purchases are associated with because you violated Gmail policy perhaps, you would be in the same boat.
Once again, not unique to Apple. Par for the DRM course.
As you point out, Steam and Xbox Live have exactly the same disturbing retroactive revocation property that Apple does; that doesn't make it any less of a horror story, just more disturbing that people put up with it. (I suspect people mostly just don't think about it, because it probably won't come up for them.)
It's true that if you use no digital services and buy almost no mobile apps, you can avoid this. That kind of blows, though.
True, I should have said the vast majority of popular digital services, not ones targeted towards the kind of people that would use an N900 to make a point.
> True, I should have said the vast majority of popular digital services, not ones targeted towards the kind of people that would use an N900 to make a point.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman ? :)
I don't think services offering the not-quite-purchase of data represent "the vast majority of popular digital services". Also, services like Netflix don't have this problem, since they very clearly position themselves as analogous to a rental, not a purchase. iTunes, the Android Market, Xbox Live, and Steam all very much position themselves as purchasing mechanisms, which makes the ability to retroactively revoke purchases unacceptable.
(And I don't use an N900 to make a point; I use it because it does the things I want it to do better than anything else I've tried, and that includes Android devices. I only mentioned it because you seemed to assume that since I didn't use iTunes or Android I must not use mobile apps at all.)
Ahh, makes sense.
> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman
I'm looking at the truest scotsman in the world right now.
> I don't think services offering the not-quite-purchase of data represent "the vast majority of popular digital services".
I would, assuming you aren't counting rental services. Netflix isn't really the same thing. I'm referring to purchasing digital goods tied to an account.
> And I don't use an N900 to make a point; I use it because it does the things I want it to do better than anything else I've tried
Right...
> and that includes Android devices. I only mentioned it because you seemed to assume that since I didn't use iTunes or Android I must not use mobile apps at all.
Nope, I assumed you use an N900 or something similar the moment you said you didn't use an Android device. You seem like the type. I stand by my original comment, there are very few mobile apps published for MeeGo. I didn't say you utilized no mobile apps, I said a small handful. Still true. Hell, for MeeGo a handful might even be overly generous.
Either way it was a very nice gesture. Cheers.
Which is disturbing but when it regards software your livelihood depends upon, not "just" games, the story gets that additional umpf.
> Once again, not unique to Apple.
Sure, but the article is about Apple.
I like the implication that nobodies livelihood depends on a game. Of course nothing could be further from the truth. I'm sorry but to find it disturbing it kind of has to be novel, and it's not.
IMO it's pretty sad that what is supposedly a community of developers is "shocked" by something that has been going on for years now on plenty of platforms, including iOS and Android. You might still have a problem with it but it shouldn't cause an incredulous reaction like that.
> Sure, but the article is about Apple.
I'm not discussing the article, I'm discussing your incredulous reaction like this is something out of some dream. It's not, in fact there is tons of precedent for it.
From what I can tell, it seems to be largely based on having a record that you've checked the box that says you've read their legal agreements.
A user was hacked so they stop allowing him to update their software?! So that it can more easily happen again?
And they will revoke his account (and license?) that allows him to use the software he bought?! This is like a horror story written by Richard Stallman.
EDIT: On second thought, why do you even need an account to update the software? When I'm updating my Ubuntu, it's the software that's signed so that I can trust the repository. The user is not signed so that the repository can trust them, you can stay completely anonymous. Hell, even Microsoft never required me to jump through any sort of hoops to get updates. I once had to verify my key, that's it. Does Android require a Google account to use the market and get updates? Even if, you still can get an anonymous one.
Why would anyone need my name to update their own software? It happens to run on my computer but that doesn't change anything.