News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by BenFranklin100 on Thursday June 22, 2023 @10:53PM (#36442262)
This is exciting, although the cost of treatment is very high. Contributing factors to the high cost is that gene therapy is a cutting edge approach with a high failure rate and thus high development costs, and DMD is a rare disease with a small patient population. In time, as the development of gene therapy treatments become more refined, costs will go down.

Successes in gene therapy treatments are exciting, as the success rate of traditional small molecule therapies have stagnated over the last 10-20 years. Moreover, small molecule therapies may never prove effective in treating many genetic diseases.

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by tptacek on Thursday June 22, 2023 @11:32PM (#36442467)
The disease itself is incredibly expensive. The price of breakthrough treatments will come down faster than the costs of having the disease.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by BenFranklin100 on Thursday June 22, 2023 @11:40PM (#36442506)
I don’t know the specifics of the costs of caring for one with DMD, but I strongly agree that in general, new disease therapies are the only sure way to drive down medical costs in the medium and long term. This represents a victory, no doubt.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by fullburley on Friday June 23, 2023 @12:28AM (#36442784)
It is very expensive. We will likely have $2M USD in insurance claims for medical this year, and our son is currently aged out of the approved label. At a gross cost of $3.2M for this treatment, its expensive but definitely cost effective relatively speaking.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by arthur2e5 on Friday June 23, 2023 @04:35AM (#36444287)
Considering this new treatment is just a single dose[^1] that hopefully lasts for quite a while[^2], it might actually cost a lot less in the long run.

[^1] see FDA press release and monograph. addditional doses won't do much because by then the immune system has learned to attack the AAV vector -- a different vector strain would be needed and that would be a new drug to be approved

[^2] no idea what the turnover rate is. and honestly, the FDA isn't even sure it helps with anything, hence conditional.

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by ramraj07 on Friday June 23, 2023 @12:32AM (#36442799)
I remember over lunch with a person researching custom DNA vaccines and he mentioned to get personalized injectable grade DNA made per person costs a million dollars. My mind was blown.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by throwaway2037 on Friday June 23, 2023 @02:06AM (#36443389)
I agree: It is mind-blowing -- the cost, but the science is also mind-blowing. This stuff really is science fiction. When I was a kid, I could never imagine it was possible. Think how primitive computers were 30 years ago. All of these bio-breakthroughs are impossible without staggering amounts of compute and improved laboratory hardware.

My thinking: How long for each divide-by-ten step? 1M USD today, 100K USD next, 10K USD later. At 10K USD, for these life threatening diseases, it is a drop in the bucket. Any insurance company would pay for it, because it would easily save many times more in avoided treatments for the illness.

Think about the revolution that 3D printers brought. I could see something similar for custom DNA vaccines. They should be targeting wealthy people who want cosmetic effects, like hair regrowth, less wrinkles, hormones like a 30 year old, etc. They can pay, and it will help to mature the industry and production pipeline.

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by 100ideas on Friday June 23, 2023 @03:00AM (#36443716)
In principle, these costs could be 1000x less. Much like minicomputer -> dell price shift.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by bboygravity on Friday June 23, 2023 @03:03AM (#36443726)
If the rate of price-decline of DNA sequencing is any referece: it took 14 years for the price of that to be devided by 100.000.

So 3,5M USD cost now would be 35 USD in 14 years (not taking into account any hyperinflation that I think is likely in that same time-frame).

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by light_hue_1 on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:15AM (#36444894)
The cost has nothing to do with the cost of sequencing DNA. DMD is extremely rare and expensive. The gene therapy itself is very cheap. The cost of the drug is entirely due to the value it provides.

The company is already talking about upping the price to $12 million.

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by throwaway2037 on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:27AM (#36445386)
To be fair, research isn't free. If the total addressable population of sick people is very tiny, then the fee needs to be enormous for each person. I am OK with some kind of rich gov't programme to negotiate and pay this fee. After R&D is paid for, plus some handsome profit, the fees can drop and we can export to developing countries.
Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by light_hue_1 on Friday June 23, 2023 @10:50AM (#36447584)
I'm not criticizing the cost at all. It's a deadly disease that ravages people's bodies and over a lifetime costs tens of millions. Even $12 million seems fair.

Just pointing out that genetics getting cheaper has no effect here.

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by throwaway2037 on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:25AM (#36445376)

    hyperinflation that I think is likely in that same time-frame
What a laugh. Every time I see people talk about economics on HN, the level of discourse is so poor and uneducated. "[H]yperinflation" - you mean like Weimar Republic where people needed wheelbarrows of money to buy a loaf of bread? Forget it. It is the stuff of fantasy. You would have a constitutional crisis in any modern democracy before it got that far. Look at the Oil Crisis(es) in the 1970s. Inflation got so out of control that Central Banks needed to jack up rates to nearly 20%, but they won. No wheelbarrows of money. We had nothing even close since then. (Here it comes: "Oh, but this time is different!" No, it isn't. So many people forget what _some_ inflation feels like. It's been 30 YEARS without inflation over 1% in Japan and it has mentally stunted the economic thinking and planning for multiple generations.)

If I could, I would sell "insurance" against hyperinflation all day long. Like taking candy from a baby; it would be such easy money. For example, write options on Fed Funds rate at 25%. You can pay me your option premium all you want.

Re:FDA Approves First Gene Therapy Treatment of Duchenne Mus... by LifeIsBio on Friday June 23, 2023 @01:23AM (#36443120)
It is exciting! As others in the thread are saying, the cost of individuals with severe rare diseases are also very high.

Here’s a recent attempt at quantifying the costs across all rare disease:

https://chiesirarediseases.com/assets/pdf/chiesiglobalraredi...