News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by JonnieCache on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @09:24AM (#3643225)
Firstly, things have changed massively since one flew over the cuccoos nest was written. It wasn't even representative at the time. As I understand, it's more an allegory for the wider society and about institutions. A modern psychiatric hospital is utterly unlike the place in that book in every respect. They still use electroshock therapy, because it has been proven to work. Now they do it under general anaesthetic and it's an altogether less messy affair. Watch this moving TED talk if you don't believe me: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEZrAGdZ1i8

Secondly, closely related to this is the famous Rosenhan experiment.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosenhan_experiment

The really relevant bit is this paragraph:

For example, one nurse labeled the note-taking of one pseudopatient as "writing behavior" and considered it pathological. The patients' normal biographies were recast in hospital records along the lines of what was expected of schizophrenics by the then-dominant theories of its etiology.

I also remember that one participant had their habit of standing around outside the cafeteria waiting for it to open for lunch noted down by a nurse as "neurotic behaviour around eating and food" and again framed as part of their disorder and used as a reason to keep them there.

Remember though that this was in america in the 70s, and things have changed a lot since then. Partly as a direct result of that study, which made a huge impact on the profession and caused a lot of soul searching. Someone repeated it, I think in the 90s, and they were all just put on pills rather than being committed. The crucial difference being that one can choose not to take pills.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by dkarl on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @11:35AM (#3643736)
Someone repeated it, I think in the 90s, and they were all just put on pills rather than being committed.

And they were probably just given pills because that's what doctors to do make their customers happy. The "anti-authoritarian" diagnoses are also demand-driven. Parents want a mental health diagnosis to explain why their kids aren't the perfect overachievers they wanted them to be, and then they want pills to make it better. The elastic definitions of mental disorders make it possible for the customer to always be right.

Nothing brings out authoritarianism like parenthood.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @09:46AM (#3643310)
Isn't this the "all politicians are untrustworthy" problem. Politicians are not any more untrustworthy or criminal than the general populace, they are just more closely watched.

And the same is obviously true of those 'under observation' - psychiatric disorders or not.

I am not sure just how many of my strange habits would be diagnosed under the DSM - but enough to worry me :-)

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by JonnieCache on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @09:54AM (#3643337)
>I am not sure just how many of my strange habits would be diagnosed under the DSM - but enough to worry me

That is exactly why doctors don't diagnose just using the DSM checklists. Obviously if they did, we'd all be mad as hatters. There are a whole load of other criteria which must be met, for example, the behaviours have to be detrimental to your life or to the lives of others around you. They also must be abnormal within your culture, which is why religious people aren't all immediately locked up and sedated.

I really wish I could remember/find the name of this other set of assessments that doctors make but alas I cannot. Also my knowledge is based on the UK system, where incidentally they use the ICD-10, which is like the european version of the DSM. Things may very well be different in the states or elsewhere.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by SimHacker on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @10:59AM (#3643571)
Our culture would benefit greatly if religious people were immediately locked up and sedated. They ARE crazy and harmful to those around them, and humoring them is bad for society.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by anti-atheist on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @04:42PM (#3645143)
yeah, it would be much better if instead of 'thou shalt not kill' we taught our children 'do unto others before they do unto you'. Don't conflate the failings of a minority with the actual religion.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by mikeash on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @11:15AM (#3643639)
I'm really curious about your politicians statement. Has it been studied and found that politicians match the population in this area, or is that just your supposition?
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by ImprovedSilence on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @04:39PM (#3645128)
I decided to look this up, and I'm actually impressed with the overview from Snoops: http://www.snopes.com/politics/crime/congress.asp

[tl:dr, they really didn't come to any conclusion]

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by c1sc0 on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @10:51AM (#3643540)
I can report firsthand (well, nearly) on the effectiveness of correctly administered electroshock therapy. My mother has been treated successfully with modern electroshock therapy for major depression. It is entirely painless and the only debilitating side-effect is memory loss. For many patients this approach is more valid than the lengthy trial-and-error approach of finding the right mix of andtidepressants. Disclaimer: my father is a biological psychiatrist, so she may have received better-than-average treatment.

What blew me away was the effectiveness: it was like rebooting a system. After the treatment an entirely different person came back.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by noduerme on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @02:17PM (#3644466)
Sorry if this is rude, but... was there at any point a discussion about the ethics involved in having one's wife rebooted and turned into an entirely different person?
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by brazzy on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @05:38PM (#3645398)
Have you ever had to deal with someone suffering from clinical depression? It is not a condition likely to have the ethics of an effective therapy doubted by anyone, including the patient.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by noduerme on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @07:18PM (#3645767)
Ah, so if the ends justify the means then there's no one qualified to question the method? Why not diagnose demonic possession and write a prescription for drowning? Who's to doubt the ethics of the method if it's "effective"?

And "effective" by whose measure, anyway? A husband who wants his wife to "act normal"? The health establishment? You?

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by jff on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:02AM (#3646640)
You're right, he should have let his wife be herself and just commit suicide.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by noduerme on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @07:36AM (#3647538)
You're assuming facts not in evidence.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by nknight on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:23PM (#3648982)
You're demonstrating a clear ignorance of what clinical depression is.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by brazzy on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @04:08AM (#3647134)
Ah, so you haven't.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by noduerme on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @07:34AM (#3647528)
I think this goes to the point of the article. You bring up "clinical depression" and immediately say that the ethics of an "effective" therapy shouldn't or can't be brought into question. At what point are mere mortals no longer allowed to question the ethics of a form of therapy...right when depression is diagnosed by a clinician? Or does your experience with depressives you know make it okay to electroshock anybody if those are the shrink's orders? If that's your view then you certainly fall well within the authoritarian camp, and it's ironic how little you took away from the article.
Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by brazzy on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @09:39AM (#3647938)
I think your loaded rhetorics are entirely divorced from reality in this point; You're painting this picture of an evil conspiracy between an authoritarian establishment and intolerant relatives using draconian brainwashing measures to attack any minor deviation from a questionable norm.

In reality, clinical depression is a condition that causes great suffering to the patient and their loved ones, and massively changes their personality (to a state where they lose all will to live). It is not something easily misdiagnosed or confused with any state anyone would want to be in.

Any effective therapy will not be questioned by anyone because the patient is too happy about getting back their ability to enjoy life, and their relatives about seeing them turn back into the person they were before.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by noduerme on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:03PM (#3648583)
Well, that's kind of the point of Brave New World; most people are happy to occupy the place they're given, take the drugs they're given, and only misfits question the validity of drugging the whole population to produce an artificial state of euphoria.

Maybe depression is a natural state that shouldn't be interfered with. It certainly leads to great works of art and literature. For all we know, it may be necessary for the fitness and survival of the species. It may be a prerequisite to civilization. So now, because society grants a license to psychologists to play God with patients' emotions, and just because you, and they, and even the patients say they're only too happy to be "cured" of their depression, that's supposed to provide a valid mandate for a license to play God?

See if you can answer this question directly: By your logic, is there any reason people should not be lobotomized if it produces a happier or calmer patient?

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by brazzy on Thursday March 01, 2012 @09:41AM (#3652210)
It's easy to sprout bullshit (yes, bullshit, unmitigated) about "natural state that shouldn't be interfered with" and "playing God" when it's not yourself or your loved ones that suffer from a debiliating disease.

See if you can answer this question directy: by your logic, is there any reason to cure any disease at all because "for all we know" some may be necessary for the fitness and survival of the species, and some inspire great art?

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by noduerme on Thursday March 01, 2012 @03:06PM (#3653770)
It's a moot question, because by my logic, 90% of what's diagnosed as "clinical depression" is actually a correct reaction to living in an atomized, alienating society driven by pharmaceuticals marketers and authoritarians who demand that everyone wear a happy face (and who attack anyone who dares to claim that we're not all meant to wear a happy face).

See, this is why I'd never visit a shrink. But there's always some sanctimonious jackass who thinks he's so happy, everyone who isn't as happy as he is should be doped in the interest of the public good. It's hard to express the absolute loathing I have for your assumptions about my experiences with depression, or your drippingly patronizing tone, other than to compare it with my feeling for other kinds of teetotalers and those authoritarians who profess to know what's in everyone else's best interest. Luckily most of them are powerless and cowardly, and can't get their hands on me or my loved ones to lobotomize.

I love my loved ones the way they are, depressed or otherwise. Since you didn't answer my question, this is the end of our conversation. Thanks and goodnight.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by Alex3917 on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @10:49AM (#3643535)
"Firstly, things have changed massively since one flew over the cuccoos nest was written. [...] A modern psychiatric hospital is utterly unlike the place in that book in every respect."

Why do you say this? From everything I've read I don't think there have been many changes at all.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by cgoddard on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @09:01PM (#3646063)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalization

Granted letting people fend for themselves on the streets and be poor and destitute through financial marginalization isn't always a lot better.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by JonnieCache on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @10:58AM (#3643565)
I've seen the inside of (admittedly only one of) them, although not as a patient. My father is a psychiatrist.

I admit that they probably bear some similarities in the patterns of procedure and behaviour that take place in them, but they are not the stark, inhumane, prisonlike environments portrayed in that book/film. You're right though, "utterly unlike in every respect" is probably too strong.

Re:Why Anti-Authoritarians are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill by nknight on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @11:46AM (#3643780)
> I've seen the inside of (admittedly only one of) them, although not as a patient. My father is a psychiatrist.

So you lack first-hand knowledge, and your argument is easily seen as a biased defense of a family member -- an authority figure, even.

I don't think you're helping your cause any.