News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by BossingAround on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:34PM (#36420771)
I don't get what's the big deal--essentially the only thing being lost is a pointer to commit that marks the difference between RHEL X.Y and X.Y+1..?
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by marwatk on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:47PM (#36420996)
RedHat spends a lot of time back-porting security updates to older software (e.g. RHEL7). Stream is always only the latest RHEL version, I believe.

The whole point of RHEL is the long term support (the back-porting), which is what they're going to stop publishing.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by trufas on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:58PM (#36421150)
CentOS 7 is supported and will be EOL at the same time as RHEL 7.

Stream does have major versions so you can continue to use CentOS Stream 8 and get backports. You only lose anything if you're tied to some minor version of EL for some reason.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pavon on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:52PM (#36421058)
RHEL X.Y isn't a simple snapshot of CentOS Stream X at a specific point. It is a fork of CentOS Stream, with cherry-picks and so on. The specific details of what patches made it into RHEL and when and how to create reproducible builds are now only being provided to customers.

In the past, customers have been able to redistribute the RHEL repos freely. I assume that will remain the case as long as CentOS Stream is open source.

Edit: Actually, it wouldn't surprise me if IBM put some content in the RHEL repo that is under restrictive licenses that couldn't be redistributed just to complicate things, but all the important parts will remain open source, due to close ties to CentOS Stream and Fedora. Rocky/Alma already have to replace trademarks, and this wouldn't be much different, but they would have to obtain access to the repos as customers themselves, or have another customer strip the bad stuff out before throwing it over the fence. We'll have to see how hostile they want to be about it.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by mroche on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:05PM (#36422048)
> In the past, customers have been able to redistribute the RHEL repos freely. I assume that will remain the case as long as CentOS Stream is open source.

There's a duality here. Yes, by the nature of the distribution, GPL, and licensing general, Red Hat cannot stop or prevent a customer from distributing RHEL packages and software to third parties. However, Red Hat reserves the right to terminate any existing subscriptions a customer may have as a result of their package distributing. IIRC, the Enterprise Agreement makes it pretty clear the services and offerings provided by the subscription are for the customer and the customer only. Going outside of that violates the subscription's terms, not the softwares' licenses, therefore allowing Red Hat to end business with said customer.

For those concerned about the final year of CentOS 7: it will not be touched. It will continue to see source exports to git.centos.org as there is no parallel CentOS Stream 7 platform. Also, git.centos.org is not EOL either because it is used by other groups than Red Hat, like CentOS Special Interest Groups.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Phrodo_00 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:46PM (#36422628)
> Red Hat cannot stop or prevent a customer from distributing RHEL packages and software to third parties. However, Red Hat reserves the right to terminate any existing subscriptions a customer may have as a result of their package distributing.

IANAL, but not so sure about that. From GPLv3:

> You may not impose any further restrictions on the exercise of the rights granted or affirmed under this License. For example, you may not impose a license fee, royalty, or other charge for exercise of rights granted under this License, and you may not initiate litigation (including a cross-claim or counterclaim in a lawsuit) alleging that any patent claim is infringed by making, using, selling, offering for sale, or importing the Program or any portion of it.

That sounds like a further restriction.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by pavon on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:25PM (#36423126)
Yeah this is really pushing a gray area. Looking at it one way Red Hat is not obligated to do business with anyone, and if they stop doing business with a customer that customer still has all the rights granted to them by licenses of software they have already received, so in that sense Red Hat hasn't restricted the customer's rights in that software.

However, on the other hand refusing to do business with someone in retaliation for exercising the rights granted by the licenses smells a lot like a restriction.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by 0x0000000 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:20PM (#36423074)
Linux is GPLv2, not Linux GPLv3. V2 does have a similar line in it:

> You may not impose any further restrictions on the recipients' exercise of the rights granted herein.

But I expect we'd have to see litigation to determine how broadly that can be interpreted.

Is applying a consequence as a result of an action the same as restricting that action?

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Phrodo_00 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:27PM (#36423162)
> Is applying a consequence as a result of an action the same as restricting that action?

I mean, I don't disagree this needs to be tested in court if it hasn't, but what alternative ways of restriction do you think this is referring to? Do you expect it to only apply to the distributor physically restraining the licensee when attempting to redistribute it? Even the examples given in the license such as imposing fees are applying a consequence.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by vamega on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @05:19PM (#36424720)
I don't think it is a further restriction on the rights you have. Those rights extend to the code you have, they are only terminating the business relationship going forward.

Not a lawyer, so maybe someone else more knowledgeable about the space will expand on this.

I imagine that RH/IBM has had lawyers look into this before the policy was announced.

Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by Phrodo_00 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @07:54PM (#36426417)
RH hasn't said that they're looking into stopping customers from redistributing free software.
Re:Red Hat cutting back RHEL source availability by JeremyNT on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:46PM (#36423385)
> Actually, it wouldn't surprise me if IBM put some content in the RHEL repo that is under restrictive licenses that couldn't be redistributed just to complicate things, but all the important parts will remain open source, due to close ties to CentOS Stream and Fedora.

I'm not so sure. They're obligated to release the GPL'd code, which of course covers Linux itself, but they're under no such obligation for the non-GPL'd software they include.

They could license their RHEL-specific backport patches for non-GPL'd software such that they could not be redistributed, and if that code gets merged into CentOS Stream it could just be dual licensed from that port forward (so Stream could stay open but RHEL would be locked down).