Re:Ego and Math – 3B1B 2023 Stanford Math Department Commenc...
by kandel on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @11:48AM
(#36420090)
mathematicians: Humanities are stressful because you don't know what's the right answer!
Re:Ego and Math – 3B1B 2023 Stanford Math Department Commenc...
by hgsgm on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:10PM
(#36421342)
Good academics fear the difficulty of good humanities. Bad academics enjoy having the excuse.
This is why "humanities" in general have a terrible reputation, but the individual people who've done great work are respected.
Re:Ego and Math – 3B1B 2023 Stanford Math Department Commenc...
by Tainnor on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @05:19PM
(#36424729)
As someone who has studied both humanities and "hard" subjects, I'd definitely say that I respect really good researchers in the humanities just as much as I would a Fields medalist, but there's a much lower bar and there's a lot of shoddy research being done (as well as really bad students who just coast by somehow, something which is much harder to do in math-heavy subjects).
Then there's also the problem that there's not even a clear consensus on what great research is in a "soft" field. I might find someone highly accomplished, but someone else might think the opposite. With maths, either someone proves a theorem or they don't, there's almost no middle ground (Mochizuki notwithstanding).
I preferred humanities, where there was wiggle room and you could bullshit your way around the gray areas. That all ended when I became a dev, where failure is nearly constant so there's no time for feeling bad about it.