News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by parsnips on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:45PM (#3640065)
This is disingenuous, Accuweather is headquartered in College Station, PA... The state that Santorum represented as senator. The owners, employees at Accuweather are his constituents.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by mbell on Monday February 27, 2012 @08:53PM (#3641460)
You've managed to cover so much that is wrong with our current political system in so few words that I can't even down vote you, It's simply impressive.

The job of the government, and in this case, the senate, is to represent the populous, in this case the state, not play special party to any particular organization.

Accuweather has fewer than 500 employees many of whom are not even in Pennsylvania, meanwhile Pennsylvania has a population of almost 13 million.

So why exactly is it that you think it is 'just', 'correct' or any other possible form of 'right' for this senator to support this company for any other reason than it being in the best interests of his _true_ constituents? That is, the people he represents that are not in the, at most, ~.0035% of his states population that work at accuweather?

Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by djtriptych on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:51PM (#3640092)
so... what part is disingenuous?
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by parsnips on Monday February 27, 2012 @02:03PM (#3640148)
The insinuation that as a Senator, your priority should be supporting open data standards vs representing the constituents you're elected to represent.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by Klinky on Monday February 27, 2012 @02:42PM (#3640328)
You know there are 12,000,000+ people in PA, the entire state is not employed by AccuWeather.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by parsnips on Monday February 27, 2012 @03:09PM (#3640413)
12,000,000 people who are building competitor weather services using public domain data? Less than 1% of the populace there probably knows they can get public domain data, let alone build a weather competitor business... which is really what the OP was complaining about.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by baconner on Monday February 27, 2012 @04:56PM (#3640838)
No, 120,000,000 people who might benefit from apps built by others on the open data.

It is good IMO for a rep to fight for legislation that helps local businesses when that action serves his constituents as a group over the long term.

That's not the case here because what Santorum did is attempt to artificially block competition in a space where competition is likely to benefit all of his constituents in the long term. It's selling out the majority for the sake of one small business and creating a wasteful bit of government that small gov types like Santorum ought to be fighting against. It's creating a barrier to free market completion for the sake of a small win for one small company.

Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by stinkytaco on Monday February 27, 2012 @06:20PM (#3641097)
One could argue that a taxpayer subsidized weather service kills private competition. How do you compete with free?

Of course, all those arguments miss the point. The weather service is an important function of the government, we shouldn't have to pay for weather. It's a matter of public safety and information, the property of the commons, not some commodity. Protecting that is the reason we have a government, not to artificially support a Senator's local business.

Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by baconner on Monday February 27, 2012 @07:58PM (#3641334)
I completely agree with your reasoning on why weather data is public data. Its actually not an argument about business at all but one of the public interest.

To expand on you reasoning a bit I think there is a general test we can apply to all government data collection and publishing practices. If the data is being collected then its been determined to be in the public's interest to do so and therefore it's also in the public interest to release it freely in a reasonably accessible format. If the set is not useful then releasing it serves to at least inform citizens that we're wasting money so we can exert pressure to stop collecting the useless set.

The exception of course is gov data that may have privacy or security implications but nevertheless eventually it should be released when those concerns are no longer valid.

Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by djtriptych on Monday February 27, 2012 @03:15PM (#3640436)
Please never run for office.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by anigbrowl on Monday February 27, 2012 @03:43PM (#3640539)
Yes, you should be doing that. House members can run on bringing home the bacon - though not at the expense of monopolistic policies, in my view. Senate members are supposed to be above such things, in theory, an represent the national interest rather than the provincial one.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by pyre on Monday February 27, 2012 @03:54PM (#3640597)
In theory, Senators are supposed to represent the State's interest. Originally, they were appointed by state government rather than elected, IIRC.
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by anigbrowl on Monday February 27, 2012 @10:26PM (#3641751)
They were appointed once, yes. Purpose is in the eye of the beholder to a large extent; it seems to me that the Constitution's authors saw the purpose of the upper chamber primarily as a check on the populist passions of the lower one, and specified the appointment of senators precisely to avoid them being beholden to public opinion in the their state of origin. Then again, the same people preferred the idea of Senator being a lifetime appointment, somewhat like the House of Lords in Britain...
Re:KML shapes of any US state, city, or county, made possibl... by officemonkey on Monday February 27, 2012 @07:21PM (#3641241)
Jerry Sandusky is also from Pennsylvania. Would you have Santorum lobby for his pardon?