I could care less about being known as the best programmer in the world, I want to be guy people turn to when they have a problem. By the time people realize they need a developer it's so far down the food chain that most of the value has been extracted by people who go to breakfast lunch and dinner with people. People who network create value, people who code create software.
But yes, developers should become better at extracting the value they create.
It's difficult to compare a large group of people based on their websites though- you can't exactly tabulate the data. I suspect that's the idea behind Coderwall- that companies will pay to mine data and find prospective employees.
I don't think Coderwall will/is meant to replace individual web sites, though.
I've done both sides of the game, but I sure know that my skills at slinging HTML and CSS didn't improve whilst I was deep in backend C code.
Throwing this out there: awesome developers could and probably should be able to make anything that coderwall could offer in terms of awesome profiles. IMO the best way to stand out is to build your own website with some open source stuff, put up your projects, and have a few links to online accounts that you put a lot of effort into making useful. By using coderwall, it looks like a developer would be only gaining access to people who are too lazy to look through their awesome website.
There is a Mark Twain quote that is escaping me that would really apply here. Something to do with crowds and what to do when everybody else is doing or thinking something.
EDIT: They have a very pretty website though. Kudos for that.