News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by TeMPOraL on Monday June 19, 2023 @04:43PM (#36396221)
Everyone seems to chime in with comments confirming your experience, so let me add an opposite take: all IKEA furniture I ever dealt with were... at best, meh. Some may look almost durable when assembled, but they start to accumulate damage over months to years of regular use. Not careless use, but also not super-careful use as if it were a museum piece. Just regular use.

Which is why I too claim that all IKEA furniture I dealt with can barely survive disassembly and reassembly - by the time I wanted them moved somewhere, they've accumulated too much structural damage.

More recently - i.e. in the last 5-8 years - all the new IKEA furniture I dealt with felt... flimsy and dangerous out of the box. Now, a wobbly wardrobe or a bookshelf that looks like it'll break apart if you push it sideways is tolerable in an apartment with two sober, working adults - but the moment a child was to enter the picture, we made sure to screw all IKEA furniture to the wall, and ever since, we don't assemble wardrobes and other "fixed" furniture ourselves - we pay a handyman to do it, and to reinforce them structurally with metal elements and glue, and then screw them to the walls or otherwise do whatever is necessary to ensure nothing will collapse or topple when mishandled by a small child.

In short: to me, IKEA furniture looks nice until you start using it, and is otherwise rather fragile. But it's cheap, and still miles better than any other flat-pack furniture vendor, so like everyone else, that's what we buy.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by adrian_b on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:37PM (#36396781)
I suppose that how durable IKEA furniture is depends a lot on what you choose.

For instance I have bought some IKEA metallic tables and these do not contain anything that is fragile or that may be damaged without a huge effort to do that.

After some 5 years there is no visible difference from the day when I have assembled them and I do not expect any to appear soon.

If I had bought some flimsy tables made of some wood substitute or dubious plastic, then yes, I would have expected them to not age well.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by civilitty on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:34PM (#36397783)
> I suppose that how durable IKEA furniture is depends a lot on what you choose.

It absolutely does. They have several quality/price tiers for most IKEA furniture that rather predictable goes from particle board to plywood to solid wood. The materials are listed on the tag in the IKEA showroom so I literally just look for the product that have only solid wood (and veneer if applicable).

The particle board is crap that quickly deteriorates, especially if you spill anything on the exposed particle board. The plywood is actually quite good if you apply a little wood glue to the joints, and the solid wood is usually the best bang for the buck furniture you can buy outside of craigslist heirloom pieces.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by codetrotter on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:31PM (#36396735)
> all IKEA furniture I ever dealt with were... at best, meh

Also, can we get a raise of hands on the number of people who have vs have not been successful in disassembling and reassembling IKEA BILLY bookshelves? I am fully convinced that it is near impossible for your average person to disassemble and reassemble BILLY bookshelves without damage.

I have a number of shelves possibly still sitting in storage at the university I studied at years ago, of all places. For two reasons. One, that I could not find anyone to help me get back in the room where they are stored after I left said university. Two, because I was so sceptical of ever being able to disassemble those bookshelves that I thought it better to leave them there until I could find a way to transport them without having to disassemble them again.

It's been years. I wonder if the shelves are still down there in the dank basement of the chemistry building of the University of Oslo alongside other PING student union things.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by TeMPOraL on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:48PM (#36396892)
I'm definitely keeping my hands down. IKEA BILLY are the ones we've inherited from the previous owners when moving in to the current apartment, and we had a handyman reinforce each one in the entire row with angle braces, and then screw them together so they don't flex independently, and then screw them to the wall - and only at that point we felt comfortable enough to start putting books into them.

We've also inherited a few spare elements for BILLYs, I think some doors and shelves, never unpacked. I believe the previous owner gave up at the idea of attaching them to the assembled bookshelves, and never bothered to return them to the store.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by makeitdouble on Monday June 19, 2023 @06:25PM (#36397219)
BILLY is the shelf where you stop the back panel with nails or rivets, right ?

It's absolutely not made to be disasembled. You'd need to go with the HEMNES line to have something a bit more solid and well thought out.

People put all IKEA stuff in the same basket, but they have different designers who can have pretty different philosophies on how the furnitures are structured. Some are really clever, others really cheap and dumb. Their EXPEDIT / KALLAX line is another line that is extremely good regarding flexibility and modularity. We actually use two as bookshelves.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by selcuka on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:31PM (#36397767)
I disassembled and reassembled BILLY bookshelves after 4 years without any visible damage, and they served for another 3+ years until I moved overseas and sold them. Not sure if they survived the second move, but they definitely did the first time.
Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by funcDropShadow on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @02:20AM (#36400391)
I've got four BILLY bookshelves that are 24 years old. I've taking them with me the eight times I moved. And they were disassembled multiple times. But I am not sure whether any currently sold BILLY bookshelves would be that durable.
Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by Gare on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:06PM (#36396469)
> we made sure to screw all IKEA furniture to the wall

That's what the instructions tell you to do

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by TeMPOraL on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:25PM (#36396670)
I'll check next time, because I've never noticed it, nor have I seen many people doing it.
Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by johnmaguire on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:39PM (#36396811)
It is in the instructions (which typically don't have words, IIRC.) Brackets have been included with all shelves we've purchased - even ones that seem short & sturdy enough to use it.

IKEA also sells furniture of varying qualities - for example, KALLAX is a well-known line of shelves that many vinyl enthusiasts use to store records. Records are extremely heavy, but these stand the test of time.

Another example is in the bedroom department: MALM vs KULLEN. The former is much thicker and sturdier, with drawers that have metal hardware. Kullen on the other hand is thinner, flimsy, and uses plastic hardware for the drawers, giving them an awful tactile feel.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by Groxx on Monday June 19, 2023 @06:31PM (#36397267)
To +1 this: it's in the instructions for every shelving unit you can buy, because it's a major safety issue regardless of construction (unless it's impractically deep compared to its height). It isn't the construction that makes them tip, it's the dimensions. If it doesn't warn you, it's because they assume you know the risk of things falling onto you, and/or they aren't willing to spend a tiny bit of money to warn you and provide anchoring locations/tools.

Which absolutely do exist. But they're not any safer due to cutting corners on safety. IKEA deserves applause for the consistent warning and hardware.

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by iudqnolq on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @01:50AM (#36400222)
"After recalling millions of tip-prone dressers that killed at least nine children and injured dozens, Ikea said shoppers must acknowledge the risk that furniture could tip over onto children before making a purchase."

https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/shopping/2021/01/29/ike...

Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by jen20 on Monday June 19, 2023 @10:38PM (#36399087)
If you buy a dresser at IKEA in the US of late, you have to attest _at the checkout_ that you will attach the item to a wall.
Re:IKEA-Oriented Development by philjohn on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:19PM (#36396613)
I mean, drawers and bookshelves should always be attached to the wall.