And they have a mechanism of achieving it: hiring and firing.
The author is right, managers are not responsible for individual’s success, their ability to persevere, time manage and so on. We work with adults, they have their parts to do.
This is me, and I completely agree. I'm on the road back to an IC role. I could continue with being a manager; I'm okay at it, and there's enough room for me to grow into the role. I've been given clarity on a career path and confidence that I can take that path.
But I'm not _good_ at it, not really, and a lot of that badness is in the disjoint of skills that I didnt bring over from technical leadership. Those skills I'm actually quite poor at and, while I can continue to improve, I don't want to because I don't enjoy exercising them.
One example of this is that I love coaching and mentoring but I hate performance reviewing. And I'm bad at it. I wrote a promotion case for someone that was lauded as one of the best of the cycle, but my reviews of substandard reports were met with harsh but fair critique.
I'm a fairweather manager and as a result I don't think I can be a good manager without living with a lot of discomfort and accepting a lot of deficit in my skills that will be more difficult to overcome given this discomfort.
I'd rather have this, I might the only person, otherwise things are going to take longer and you end up not being that good. I harsh to myself because of this, It's not fun I know. but otherwise....
One way I've thought of it recently is in terms of Radical Candor and it's concept of "ruinous empathy": if it means changing myself so significantly in my core beliefs and feelings, I think I'd rather be ruined by empathy. Equally, I need my own manager to not be ruinously empathetic, so I appreciate it makes me a bit of a hypocrite.
but leadership is not management.
And i fully agree that management is "nuanced social and political task" . And politics is contradictory to most structured stuff, esp. software.
But still, if someone does not want to know/grow, no point pushing. It's painful at both sides. May need completely different approach, mostly outside the scope of team.
At the end of the day, as a manager, you are responsible for the teams success and failure. You don't really get to say "sorry we delivered late and/or over budget, a single contributor on our team is failing to execute well and thats not MY problem". A manager is responsible for a projects failure or success which, yes, means being responsible for employees who seem to be failing at the task.
What being responsible means is the more complicated question completely brushed over in this article. Do you fire them? do you 'create a better environment' - how and how do you do it without impacting the team, projects, or budget.
Being a manager is an extremely nuanced social and political task that i dont think a large majority of people are skilled to do. Being highly technical or having decades of experience doing the technical part of the job will not prepare you for managing people, unfortunately.