Do you have benchmarks on current gen hardware that suggest that the code complexity results in a measurable difference in outcomes?
Also, I don’t think that it could even in principle be efficiently branch predicted — you are basically doing a memory read, jump conditionally based on that, jump back, do another memory read vs memory read, jump there, memory read, jump there. There is one less jump involved here, so any form of improved branch prediction would also enhance this second form as well.
I found this, you might be able to benchmark it yourself if you have better hardware: https://github.com/vshymanskyy/interp
No, cos I said "the benchmarks speak for themselves". But I am trying to understand why it's better and under what circumstances.
"...and the goto version is 25% faster than the switch version...
Comments inside the CPython implementation note that using computed goto made the Python VM 15-20% faster"
(Which isn't the 2-4x speed up that you found).
In that link they say that part of the reason is because of the bounds checking which is automatically done by the switch statement.
What I'm struggling with which is no doubt down to my lack of knowledge, is why it should be significantly faster (if you take out or disable the bounds checking added by the switch). I can see there would be some advantage in spreading out the jumps so the branch predictor could work a bit better, but I am surprised at the speed up. I guess mispredicted branches are so expensive that doing just a little bit better could account for the difference, but I am trying to understand it.
(Source: have written a JVM interpreter with the naive approach that is approximately that much slower than the OpenJDK with disabled JIT compiler. It was later also confirmed by people working on the actual JVM that that’s roughly the order of difference between the two approaches. Unfortunately I can’t find a great article on the topic right now (google is beyond useless recently)).
The article is about a further small improvement over this much larger and commonly implemented one.