News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Sunday June 18, 2023 @03:44PM (#36383694)
What if I leave for work for a year? Or 4? What is a "good" reason? If I own a house and left for a decade to binge drink, why should that mean I don't keep my paid for property? At what threshold do you tell someone: fuck you and your property, we are taking it because we want it. If siblings inherit, should only the ones who live there have any rights to it?
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by crmd on Sunday June 18, 2023 @04:29PM (#36384133)
Rent it out to strangers, let friends live there for free if you want. Do anything other than letting a home sit vacant when there are tons of unhoused people sleeping in the street.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by mozman on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:08PM (#36384500)
renters are a liability.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by ajross on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:15PM (#36384559)
So are taxes and trees, but you have to pay them and hold insurance anyway. The point is that society as a whole has interest in the community in which that home exists, and it regulates the behavior of homeowners for the benefit of everyone.

"Your home has to have people in it" is, 100%, a valid policy goal. And in extremis, paradigms like adverse possession exist to ensure this.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:33PM (#36384737)
I'm sorry, how do taxes or trees destroy the value of a property? Tenants absolutely can ruin a house. Imagine the surprise when you find out the tenants have done more damage to a property than their rent covers.

Yes, people need and should be housed. No, that doesn't mean they need _my_ house. Build up public housing resources. If the govt wants to buy my property at market rate and give it away, and I agree to sell, go for it.

Otherwise, I hear you have a good retirement fund that you spent years building. I didn't didn't do that, so just give me half of what you saved and we will call it fair.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by nmfisher on Sunday June 18, 2023 @10:52PM (#36386825)
The reasonable compromise is to heavily tax vacant properties and spend the revenue building public housing.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by mozman on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:26AM (#36387605)
We need to improve our mental health care system and get these people working, so they can rent. There isnt a shortage of homes, just a shortage of money to pay rent.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by nmfisher on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:12AM (#36388938)
In my home country (Australia), there literally is a shortage of homes at the moment. I don't think a vacancy tax would help much, but it's probably a good idea anyway.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by mozman on Monday June 19, 2023 @08:42AM (#36390418)
I can't agree with more taxes "just it's because it's a good idea". I pay a lot of money every year in tax, I don't need to pay more.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by nmfisher on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:57AM (#36415277)
Then don't leave your property vacant?
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by mozman on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @09:30AM (#36418203)
My financial decisions are nobody else's business. A lot of people here earn a lot in software, and if they want a summer home that is their prerogative. The group think on this is hard.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:20PM (#36384610)
I love extending arguments to logical absurdity to see where they fall apart. I have an airbrush my mom gave me when I was a teen. It has sentimental value. I've not used it in 20 years. Should I be forced to sell or rent it out? Or my MRE (Meals Ready To Eat) collection is over 10 years old now. Should I be forced to sell them to the hungry? How is that different than real estate?

All resources are scarce including life saving medical tech. Do you force redistribution on all resources and assets?

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by getmeinrn on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:36PM (#36384757)
I'm not taking a side here, but not every law has to extend to the general case for it to fix a problem. If we required that, there would be almost no laws.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:05AM (#36389639)
That is not what my questions are for. My examples are obviously absurd. That is the point. Where is the line?

Kind of reminds me if the old joke:

A guy asks a gal if she'll sleep with him for $10M. She, says yes. He asks what about for $100 and she is offended: "what kind of woman do you think I am!?" To which he replies, "we've already determined that, now we are just haggling over the price."

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by ajross on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:30PM (#36384712)
With all respect: what you're employing is a good dictionary definition for a glibertarian argument. "The government shouldn't make a rule because at it's 'logical absurdity' the argument falls apart" is in more typical terminology a absolutely ridiculous strawman.

You obviously don't seize obscure collectibles because there's limited public interest in such a collection. But that too has limits at the "logical absurdity" extreme: you might seize a historical artifact or painting from a private collector because it was looted from a museum 90 years ago before re-entering the private market after a few decades.

And, yeah, you might seize an abandoned property to prevent the community it's in from decaying.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:41PM (#36384810)
Abandoned. I think that is the delineation. Great point!

I feel that if you can show something is abandoned, it can be up for grabs, including my personal property.

Now to define "abandoned."

In my home town, a potentially lucrative piece of real estate was fenced and not maintained because the owner was pissed at the city. The only reason they held it was because "fuck you city." I could see an argument as saying that it is abandoned and should be forced to be used. I can also see that as free speech because the owner was making a statement about local ordinances. Is it abandoned or an active political statement?

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by brewdad on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:58PM (#36384940)
I see an argument for the addition of the fence as "improving" the property and therefore showing that it has not been abandoned.

Aside from the obvious goal of keeping out trespassers, I'd be willing to bet the fence was added based on legal advice. In a few years there will probably need to be some further "improvement". Perhaps as simple as replacing the fence.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by vintermann on Monday June 19, 2023 @04:47AM (#36388765)
> Now to define "abandoned."

We're going to do that on a case by case basis depending on reasonable things like the user's need for it, other people's need for it, what the neighbours think of it etc.

With courts and whatnot.

And there's nothing you can do about it.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by oh_sigh on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:42AM (#36387691)
Less than 0.2% of the population is homeless. And many of them would probably have a place to stay(with family or friends) if they were capable of successfully living in a house.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by ajross on Sunday June 18, 2023 @03:53PM (#36383791)
That's right, there are tradeoffs. So an absolute answer isn't the right solution here and we need to come up with policies that meet everyone's needs.

To pick your first example: keeping your old home while you work abroad for a year seems not unreasonable. But demanding that you place it on the market as a rental (or sell it) if you're gone for 4-10 (!) seems likewise like a very reasonable regulation to me.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by user432678 on Monday June 19, 2023 @09:38AM (#36390965)
Where should I put my stuff, while the property is being rented? What if I get fired and need to return in a short notice (working on a worker’s visa)?

My situation is exactly that, I left my apartment first time for 3 years. Got fired and had to return. This time it’s six years already, haven’t been “home” even once since then. I don’t have anyone to help me manage the rental. Not selling the apartment right now because I’m waiting for citizenship in a different country. Which might not work out, thus I’ll need a place to return to. Yes, my situation is anecdotal, can’t disagree. But forcing me to rent out with more taxes doesn’t sound fair as well. Especially that in many places it’s the government who created all that bureaucracy which prevents people to build new houses inflating prices and all that.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by throwaway290 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @11:08PM (#36386905)
> What if I leave for work for a year? Or 4? What is a "good" reason?

Where do you live during that time?

> why should that mean I don't keep my paid for property?

Because someone may want to live somewhere but land is too expensive because everyone is hoarding it?

> At what threshold do you tell someone: fuck you and your property, we are taking it because we want it.

"residential housing not being used as a residence for more than N years"?

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Monday June 19, 2023 @12:07AM (#36387228)
>> What if I leave for work for a year? Or 4? What is a "good" reason?

> Where do you live during that time?

Antarctic Research Station followed by a backpacking trip through Europe.

>> why should that mean I don't keep my paid for property?

> Because someone may want to live somewhere but land is too expensive because everyone is hoarding it?

Food gets expensive; let the hungry take, literally, from your kitchen? Not everyone can live in downtown, some must go to the sticks. West Virginia has some land at $1000 an acre. What is the right density in the city? How small should homes be? How many to a room?

>> At what threshold do you tell someone: fuck you and your property, we are taking it because we want it.

> "residential housing not being used as a residence for more than N years"?

Prove I didn't stop by for a few days N-1 years ago.

--

Affordable housing is a real need, and local governments and city planners should work to make that so. You don't get to take my family's nth-generation home because my area is popular and we don't use it in a way you approve.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by throwaway290 on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:53AM (#36389978)
So essentially you have no use for land/housing for extended period of time but you want to keep it. That's the textbook definition of hoarding real estate.

And please don't give this BS about generations. Just ask yourself: would you sell your grandgrandpa's home if you knew tomorrow its price was not up but got halved, day after day? There's the answer about your true motivations.

> Prove I didn't stop by for a few days N-1 years ago.

Stopping by != using as residence. I stop by local Mcd occasionally, don't mean I live there.

I'm vehemently not a communist but this sort of entitlement is cancer on humanity. Land is zero sum and a commons. These things are never not regulated in a healthy society. Even in US owning estate never means you are free to do anything you want with it, even if you live in it. Not hoarding it is only another one of those rules, sadly not supported by law enough.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Monday June 19, 2023 @12:22PM (#36392872)
Define having "no use." Lots of things can look like no or poor use. Waiting to retire there for instance. Land preservation. Political statements.

Would I sell my grandpa's house? Depends on if I want to move in later, or help my kids move in when they are out of the house in N years. Just because you might abandon a family cabin/estate/ranch/remote-land knowing the price will drop doesn't mean others will.

And how long must one inhabit a property per what unit of duration to maintain ownership? 1 month a year? 6+ months a decade?

In my case, I'm talking 10 acres off some highway in Montana. I'll sell it if or when it is necessary. I'm working out of state, so I have two homes.

You want some real estate? Work your ass off, save money, invest in yourself. Might have to move. Might have to change your lifestyle. I couldn't afford California so I had to leave. Poor people emigrate still and provide better lives for their kids. Not everyone gets to live in their favorite city. Sucks.

Sell your iPhone and buy an acre in West Virginia.

Look, there are inequities and basic needs can be hard in many areas to secure. That is all of human history. We keep working at it. The solution is not to force me to sell my 10 acres in Montana.

Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by throwaway290 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:35AM (#36404657)
"Waiting" = "no use".
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by sethammons on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:30PM (#36423196)
waiting is absolutely a use. It is just not a use you agree with. Waiting for how long? Now that is a discussion. Is it abandoned or not? There is a line. I've not heard any sane proposition on that that line is. If I go on sabbatical and the world goes on lock down and you cant get back to the house for a few years, it is absolute _insanity_ to demand that house be yielded to others.
Re:Can you just move into an abandoned house? by throwaway290 on Thursday June 22, 2023 @06:23AM (#36430068)
I'm glad we agree that there is a line and there has to be regulation to enforce it.