News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by saghm on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:43PM (#36373157)
As someone who grew up Catholic but isn't now, it's always very bizarre to see stuff like this. Catholic teaching explicitly claims that the wine is miraculously transformed into the "blood of Christ", but I guess it only works if the wine doesn't have additives? It's hard enough for me to imagine a god that wants to bless his followers by letting them drink his blood; I can't take seriously a claim that he will do this _only_ if the wine doesn't have extra sugar or elderberries added to it.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by alexmolas on Saturday June 17, 2023 @02:55PM (#36373296)
The point is that Catholics believe the words that Jesus said during the last supper, and He used wine without additives. The Mass is the repetition of that last supper and the death of Jesus in the cross. So to be faithful to what Jesus did it's important to use the same type of wine He used.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by mplanchard on Saturday June 17, 2023 @04:56PM (#36374502)
I would imagine that most modern wine is not necessarily the same type as the wine that would have been used as (presumably) table wine at the last supper.

Indeed it seems likely based on archaeological evidence that common wines drunk in the region and at the time contained additives for flavor! See https://www.vivino.com/wine-news/searching-for-the-wine-from...

Furthermore, how far should one take this silly adherence to imagined fact? If we discover that in Jerusalem they drank predominantly wine from some now extinct local varietal, does that make all masses since invalid?

I, like the poster you’re replying to, grew up Catholic, and this sort of slavish adherence to stuff some church person made up at some point in the past has always struck me as one of the more ridiculous parts of the religion.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by tialaramex on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:26PM (#36374795)
Catholicism is a mass religion, which means you need to be able to have a functioning society of Catholics (whereas if you're just making a religion to get a few dozen people into your cult so you can exploit them however you please, it isn't important whether an entire working society with this religion is even possible) so the rules can't just be complete nonsense.

But on the other hand it's important for your religion to stand out. Unless it's going to result in mass persecution or genocide, you want your believers to stand out, the requirements of your religion to impact on everybody else. So you get silly rules - not really that tricky to obey but seemingly pointless because hey, if nobody is grousing about your silly rules, nobody is noticing your religion exists.

This sort of thing is only a big problem once it tilts the whole society. People will probably vary in their tolerance but somewhere between "The weird logo on my groceries apparently signifies that a specific religious group may consume this product" and "Your existence is prohibited by the established religion in this country and so you'll be executed" there's a line crossed.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by mplanchard on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:31PM (#36374860)
Yeah you’re absolutely right, and that’s a good point. For some reason to me it feels sillier to me when I have an inside perspective than looking at similar things in other religions. Because I have experienced and discarded Catholicism, those arbitrary rules strike me as particularly ridiculous. I don’t have the same knowledge of or disdain for the arbitrary rules of other religions, probably mostly because of lack of familiarity, but maybe also because I have never personally rebelled against them.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by krapp on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:04PM (#36374577)
> So to be faithful to what Jesus did it's important to use the same type of wine He used.

But the last supper wasn't a Catholic mass. Why is this one arbitrary detail so important when the entire ritual bears only a superficial resemblance to a dinner held by Jews in 33AD Jerusalem?

It seems odd that the man who said (paraphrasing because I don't want to look it up) "The Sabbath was made to serve men, not men the Sabbath" would insist on such pedantry.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by anon291 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @01:11AM (#36377516)
Well it is a mass. In the Latin rite, the only requirement for a thing to be a valid mass is for a priest to take bread and wine and say 'this is my body' and 'this is my blood'. That's it. If a priest does this with the intention to say a mass he does an illegal but otherwise valid Mass. There is no doubt to this.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by oxfordmale on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:10PM (#36374641)
There is no evidence in the bible what kind of wine Jesus used. Wine in biblical times could refer to fermented or unfermented drink.

During Jesus lifetime, there is archeological evidence that apices and fruits - including pomegranates, mandrakes, saffron and cinnamon - were used to flavour wines, and tree resin were added to help preserve them.

So, the wine drank at the Last Supper might actually resemble the mulled wine some of us drink at Christmas.

Basically, this has nothing to do with being faithful to Jesus, but more with archaic rules that were agreed upon centuries after Jesus' lifetime.They are canonical to Catholic teachings thoughm

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by tptacek on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:57PM (#36375089)
That sounds like it might be true, but whereas I can't say I'm totally sure about the church being fastidious about the wine (most people don't take wine at mass, and I certainly didn't), I know for a fact that they'd not at all scrupulous about bread; I've taken communion from consecrated ordinary leavened bread, and when that happened, the priest who did the service explained that, essentially, bread was bread, and the words were what mattered.

I'm sure there's some traditionalist Catholic rebuttal to this! And I'm fine with that. I'd just say: traditionalist Catholicism is not the same religion that ordinary mainstream Catholics practice.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by knodi123 on Saturday June 17, 2023 @06:38PM (#36375429)
> and He used wine without additives

He used a specific bottle. But catholics were pragmatic enough to say "well, surely he didn't mean that bottle specifically." And they don't latch on to the vintage, either- doesn't have to be the same grapes grown in the same region. They don't latch on to the age of the wine, or its alcohol content. But those variations don't matter! Because.... I guess because, uh.... oh heavens me-oh-my-oh, this is a pickle. Turns out it's all subjective.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by neverartful on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:08PM (#36374623)
If you're no longer Catholic why would you care one way or the other?
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by saghm on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:23PM (#36374769)
I don't think I care in any particularly strong sense, but it was part of my experience growing up, so it's hard not to have any opinion about it at all. I'm fortunate that the friends and family I have who still are members are accepting of my choice not to be a member anymore; it's not like I don't associate with anyone at all who is Catholic. At least in my immediate family, discussing religion isn't something that will cause arguments, so sometimes the topic comes up when I talk with my parents. I'm sure there are plenty of things I'd find silly in other ideologies as well; I just don't have the same level of exposure.
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by dctoedt on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:25PM (#36374781)
> If you're no longer Catholic why would you care one way or the other?

Another former Catholic here. We should all care because controversies such as these:

- divert the faithful's attention from Jesus' principal injunction that we seek the best for others — even our enemies — as we do for ourselves; and

- provide the insecure and fearful with an excuse for invidious behavior toward those who decline to follow artificial, pharisaic rules.

This harms civil society in general, not just Catholics.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by tptacek on Saturday June 17, 2023 @05:58PM (#36375098)
I'm still Catholic and these would be my reasons too. :)
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by michaelsbradley on Saturday June 17, 2023 @09:13PM (#36376378)
I’m still Catholic too, and your argument doesn’t hold water.

From the first century A.D. to the present the Church has cared about holding true to the Apostolic tradition, which includes teachings re: how to treat others as well how to worship God.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by dctoedt on Saturday June 17, 2023 @10:00PM (#36376625)
> From the first century A.D. to the present the Church has cared about holding true to the Apostolic tradition

Oh. So then I guess either Matthew or Acts got it wrong about whose name should be invoked in baptizing: If Jesus really said to baptize in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, then the apostles apparently ignored his instructions — compare Matt. 28.19 with Acts 2.38, 8.16, 10.48, 19.5. [0]

On a tangentially-related subject: Peter, preaching at Pentecost, seems to have flagrantly misrepresented his scriptural source. [1]

While we're at it: The Apostles all indisputably thought that Jesus would be returning Real Soon Now — and that just didn't happen. [2]

[0] https://www.questioningchristian.org/2004/10/troubling_incon...

[1] https://www.questioningchristian.org/2004/10/troubling_incon...

[2] https://www.questioningchristian.org/2005/10/is_jesus_coming...

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by michaelsbradley on Saturday June 17, 2023 @10:43PM (#36376850)
Well, I'm sure such a general reply won't satisfy you, but in the Catholic West and East the idea is that the teaching of the Church is the context in which one needs understand Sacred Scripture, not the other way around. More concretely, the context for understanding Matthew, Acts, et al. is the teachings of the Councils, Fathers, and Doctors of the Church, as well the lives, writing, and preaching of the Saints.

This still very much allows for disagreement on matters not formally settled, and is no barrier to a person untrained in ecclesiastical history and dogmatic theology from being edified by reading and/or hearing the Bible.

  You may know how one ought to behave in the household of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and bulwark of the truth.
— 1 Tim 3:15 (RSV)

The church is the pillar and bulwark, and we are on the surest footing when interpreting Sacred Scripture standing atop the pillar; everything else is a complete non-starter, though can be fodder for debates and whatnot.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by dctoedt on Sunday June 18, 2023 @03:04AM (#36377993)
> Well, I'm sure such a general reply won't satisfy you ....

On that much, we agree.

> the context for understanding Matthew, Acts, et al. is the teachings of the Councils, Fathers, and Doctors of the Church ....

You might consider another possibility: That the apostolic succession belongs to all the baptized, not just to what I once referred to as "the Twelve's decisions to anoint themselves as a self-perpetuating elite" in the early church. [0]

[0] https://www.questioningchristian.org/2007/02/the_apostolic_s...

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by michaelsbradley on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:28AM (#36379193)
Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by dctoedt on Sunday June 18, 2023 @08:04AM (#36379427)
Thanks for the link, which is helpful.

1. Unfalsifiable, ipse dixit proclamations by church "overseers," i.e., bishops (Greek: ἐπίσκοπος, episkopos, whence English's episcopal) aren't persuasive. I long ago read translations of the surviving writings of some of the earliest church fathers — such as in the page you linked. I was struck by the distinct impression that the first bishops essentially bootstrapped themselves into authority — they peremptorily announced:

- that they were successors of the Apostles; and

- that their apostolic succession entitled them to be in charge.

And they persuaded their (self-selected?) flocks to acknowledge their authority; eventually, what started out as an arguable heresy on the part of these "overseers" became carved in stone as a core principle of church governance. [0]

2. The church fathers relied extensively on the letters of Paul, né Saul, of Tarsus. Recall that Saul/Paul started out as a fiery persecutor of Christians — then suddenly "flipped" and became equally zealous preaching his version of Christianity.

And remember that Paul preached what he claimed to be his own gospel, not received from any man, but directly from Jesus himself, whom he had never met in life — if Paul had known Jesus before the latter's execution, he surely would have trumpeted the fact, in Galatians and elsewhere.

[0] https://www.questioningchristian.org/2006/04/what_is_the_pro...

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by anon291 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @01:08AM (#36377510)
It's not that God cannot it's that the human church cannot say for certain whether God does.

For example, God can come back tomorrow riding in from heaven on a Ford mustang but the church isn't going to declare this as true and make everyone wait for it tomorrow.

If God tells you to do X so Y happens, then you should do X. You should not do Z and then expect Y to happen with certainty. It might. It might not. You cannot know.

Re:KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms by callalex on Sunday June 18, 2023 @01:44AM (#36377633)
It reminds me a lot of the rules we used to make up while playing games during recess in primary school.