News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by fragsworth on Sunday February 26, 2012 @07:26PM (#3637295)
I am pretty sure this amounts to fraud on the part of Rumblefish.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by epoxyhockey on Sunday February 26, 2012 @09:24PM (#3637539)
I would love it if Google would revoke Rumblefish's earnings/account in the same fashion that they revoke mom & pop AdSense publishers, like: "Your account has been terminated. All of your earnings have been returned to the advertisers. There is no appeal. Goodbye."

Seriously, Rumblefish's behavior reminds me of a certain CEO I used to work for. The guy would rip off just about anyone he could (including his employees) by exploiting loopholes. Some of the exploits worked, others didn't. But, he would hold out a carrot just far enough to avoid a critical mass of lawsuits.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by beedogs on Monday February 27, 2012 @12:59AM (#3637939)
This happened to a friend of mine with no warning and no explanation. He appealed and was soundly rejected, again with no explanation. He ran a nutrition blog and created all of the content himself.

Google's business model seems to involve fucking over anyone who can't sue them.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by mistercow on Monday February 27, 2012 @10:48AM (#3639335)
Something similar happened to me years ago. They accused me of "click fraud". All I can figure is that a disgruntled reader decided to click repeatedly on my ads to get me in trouble. There really isn't an appeal process. You email them asking for details, and they reply with form letters.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by beedogs on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @06:32PM (#3645583)
This is exactly what happened to him.

Apparently all it takes to kill someone's AdSense account is one person reloading and clicking through ads a few dozen times. This is pretty fucking horrible on Google's part.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by mistercow on Tuesday February 28, 2012 @08:32PM (#3645975)
Yeah, I searched after it happened to me and found a lot of cases, including a couple of angry exes.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by brazzy on Monday February 27, 2012 @04:01AM (#3638296)
How does Google profit from return revenues to advertisers?

Google's business model is reducing overheads in business processes in order to scale them down to the point where anyone can use them. This involves eliminating human participation from their side as much as possible.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by davidw on Monday February 27, 2012 @05:11AM (#3638442)
> How does Google profit from return revenues to advertisers?

"By keeping on their good side" would be my stab at that one. If the advertisers trust Google to take their side, they're more likely to spend money. Nothing particularly 'evil' about that or anything, just how it works.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by bo1024 on Sunday February 26, 2012 @09:13PM (#3637516)
Not if it's anything like the Megaupload controversy recently.

Here's the loophole. Your EULA with YouTube states that YouTube may take down your videos for any reason. YouTube also has a side deal with certain large rightsholders that they may take down videos at any time for any reason.[1] It is implied that these takedowns will be only for DMCA purposes, but since the companies never have to officially file a DMCA notice, there are never any legal repercussions for false takedowns.

Nice, eh?

[1] (Edit) Well, they are only supposed to take down videos for good reason, but we haven't seen YouTube enforce that. Either way, this is between YouTube and the rightsholders; the DMCA doesn't get involved.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by pbhjpbhj on Monday February 27, 2012 @11:37AM (#3639514)
>Your EULA with YouTube states that YouTube may take down your videos for any reason. //

Shouldn’t this prevent YouTube from relying on the common carrier defence - they're are clearly manipulating and policing the content [to benefit their commercial interests] and not acting as a common carrier.

What troubles me more is that they're somehow allowed to deny individuals their copyrights - they're putting other peoples advertising next to your content presumably without waiting for it to be acceded to. They should surely, to keep lawful, take down dubious content until the ownership of rights has been resolved.

In some jurisdictions I'd have thought that they couldn't add a EULA that would allow them to use third-party copyright material without explicit permission. That is when a corp claims your uploaded material and YouTube simply decide to add ads for that corp and send earnings to that same corp then this should (and I contend probably is in some places where YouTube are operating) be unlawful.

In short: Google are actively infringing copyright. Is a EULA statement really sufficient to make this lawful?

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by jemfinch on Sunday February 26, 2012 @09:14PM (#3637517)
Do you have any links to substantiate your claims? I'd be interested in reading the background.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by bo1024 on Sunday February 26, 2012 @09:23PM (#3637537)
Here's a few news articles. As I understand it, the only way UMG would be in legal trouble is if they violated their contract with YouTube -- that is, they promised YouTube to only take down stuff they had the rights to. So the only enforcement here is if YouTube decides to sue UMG for breach of contract. (Which I wouldn't hold my breath on.) Either way, the DMCA never gets involved because they never had to file a DMCA notice to take down YouTube content.

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/12/umg-we-have-...

http://thenextweb.com/insider/2011/12/16/youtube-denies-that...

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20111216/01463417102/explan...

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/megaupload-viral-mu...

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by ubernostrum on Sunday February 26, 2012 @11:29PM (#3637773)
Copyright law does have the tort of slander of title; if Rumblefish's actions are interpreted by a court as claiming rights Rumblefish does not have, that could be a quite serious issue separate from anything YouTube has in a contract or EULA.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by bo1024 on Monday February 27, 2012 @02:13AM (#3638091)
Ok, cool. How does that work? The original author sues in civil court? And what do we mean by "quite serious"?
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by wtallis on Monday February 27, 2012 @03:47AM (#3638260)
Probably the most notable case involving slander of title was SCO v Novell. Groklaw explained the slander of title aspect: http://www.groklaw.net/articlebasic.php?story=20040211161256...

It looks like it's not the easiest claim to prosecute, but in the case of YouTube videos where the content is entirely original and thus cannot be owned by a music label, the only hard part would be proving lost income. If that can be done, then the label can be held liable for actual and punitive damages, and legal costs.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by reader5000 on Sunday February 26, 2012 @10:26PM (#3637656)
I'm not a lawyer but I know contract law does sometimes recognize third-party rights. Not sure if would be applicable here.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by nivloc on Monday February 27, 2012 @04:06AM (#3638306)
Having seen the video (the ads are gone now, btw), it's pretty clear that no reasonable human watched it, because they'd certainly be misrepresenting ownership of the content.

'Misrepresentation of ownership causing damage to another party or benefit for oneself' is generally fraud (criminal too), but intent tends to be weighted far more than status. That said, the test is usually a good faith belief that one is the legitimate owner, and I don't know of many bots with that sort of discretion.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by Alex3917 on Sunday February 26, 2012 @09:55PM (#3637601)
Why? Birdsongs are actually copywritable music, and since they all sound fairly similar it's certainly possible that the software confused his recording with something from the Cornell lab of ornithology, which licenses their bird recordings to Hollywood, toy makers, musicians, etc.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by sp332 on Sunday February 26, 2012 @10:30PM (#3637661)
since they all sound fairly similar

That's not how copyright works. If you make an original work, it can be identical to a copyrighted work and not be infringing. It's only a problem if you make your work from the copyrighted one.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by bigiain on Sunday February 26, 2012 @11:08PM (#3637727)
I suspect Cornell do have mechanical copyright in some recordings of birdsongs - which'd allow them to charge royalties on anybody using copies of the recordings they made, but there'd be no composer or performer to own the actual "song". (Sort of like how you can't claim copyright in every photo of a sunrise just 'cause you took one, but you do have rights with regards to the particular sunrise photograph you shot.)
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by stwe on Monday February 27, 2012 @05:12AM (#3638444)
In GB the copyright definition apparently includes the mere idea of a photograph: http://www.amateurphotographer.co.uk/news/photographers_face...
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by GFischer on Thursday March 01, 2012 @01:01PM (#3653198)
In the U.S. as well.

"Infringement of Copyrighted Photographs Under U.S. Copyright law, you violate the copyright owner's exclusive rights of copying and/or to create a derivative work by creating a work that is a copy of or "substantially similar" to another's. The courts determine whether the two works are substantially similar by comparing them and evaluating whether copyrightable elements have been used in the second work. A court is much more likely to find an infringement if the subject of the photo has been "set up" by the photographer and contains creative and original elements, compared to a photograph of subjects that already exist, such as in nature or a structure such as the Golden Gate Bridge."

http://www.photoattorney.com/2008/11/does-derivative-work-vi...

The case you quote is not so easy, though.

The tough decision is if New English Teas intended to violate copyright, and if the Red Bus photos were original enough to claim copyright.

The judge decided that the Red Bus photos were original enough (creator claimed 80 hours of work), and New English Teas had used the original photos earlier on, and was made to remove them, so there was clearly intent to violate copyright. However, I'm not so sure if the Red Bus photos were original enough, or if there was intent to mislead buyers into thinking the New English Teas were Red Bus licensed.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by bigiain on Sunday February 26, 2012 @11:13PM (#3637743)
A melody has recently (here in Australia) been granted copyright protection (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_Under_%28song%29#Copyright... ).
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by jvoorhis on Monday February 27, 2012 @02:23AM (#3638109)
In the US music industry, there are separate copyrights for songwriting and recordings. If you create an original recording of a birdsong, then you hold the copyright to that recording. I don't understand how owning a copyright for a melody created and performed by birds is defensible.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by onemoreact on Monday February 27, 2012 @11:32AM (#3639492)
It's the same way you can own the copyright on a photograph. It's enough that you decided to open a sensor at a specific time and location and record a physical event.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by jvoorhis on Monday February 27, 2012 @01:11PM (#3639907)
Exactly. So if you opened the sensor, then any Rumblefish claim is invalid...
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by marquis on Monday February 27, 2012 @02:31AM (#3638127)
The music of Handel, Vivaldi and Bach et all is not copyrighted: only the recording. You are quite welcome to go make your own piano recording of the Goldberg Variations and sell this. Similarly you can't make a sellable copy of the music book you might have learnt the notes from but you can make your own interpretation from the original manuscript, or other version out of copyright, and publish this.
Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by andrewljohnson on Sunday February 26, 2012 @08:32PM (#3637426)
I - you the person, you the lawyer?

pretty sure - just guessing, sure from some other knowledge, or just misusing words?

fraud - like, they have committed a crime in some jurisdiction?

I am pretty sure this amounts to uninformed speculation.

Re:YouTube Identifies Birdsong As Copyrighted Music by ubernostrum on Sunday February 26, 2012 @11:24PM (#3637767)
Well, "fraud" in non-legal English is generally taken to mean false or deceiving statements. And falsely claiming to hold rights one does not hold is, well, a false and/or deceiving statement.

Though in the realm of copyright, "slander of title" might be the more appropriate phrase.