Re:The Stupid Programmer Manifesto
by denton-scratch on Thursday June 15, 2023 @01:48PM
(#36344127)
> Also, web-browsers don't let you copy-and-paste the password from one box into another
Point taken; perhaps simply having that widget that lets you see the password unmasked would be better, than forcing you to enter it blind twice (and getting it wrong twice). Fact is I don't try to copy/paste one field into the other; I paste the same stuff into both.
FWIW I'm a normal person. I don't know what OIDC is, and I've never been asked to use Passkeys (I'm proud to know nothing about Apple devices, and I don't entrust my security to "the cloud" or third parties). My password manager is local, backed-up locally. I'm already annoyed once I'm presented with a registration form, and only complete one when I'm forced to. Every extra annoyance increases my rage.
Re:The Stupid Programmer Manifesto
by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday June 15, 2023 @01:59PM
(#36344272)
> I don't know what OIDC is
It was a very, very painful learning experience.
I think you're really, really underestimating how easy it is to make a typo when entering a password into a masked password box, hence the 2 fields.
Also, web-browsers don't let you copy-and-paste the password from one box into another - so I don't know how you're doing that: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/149326/why-cant...
-----
I appreciate that you're just-as-annoyed with web-form tropes, cliches and irritations as I am - and when I'm building a system or UI for savvy people then sure, I'll do things like skipping the registration form entirely and just use OIDC federation or PassKeys or whatever the current-security-fad-of-the-month is - but my day-job requires me to write software for ...uh... "normal people" and part of that means having to weigh-up the support-costs of users who want a predictable and easy-to-understand that isn't too different from what they already know - and those normal-people are what pays my bills.