...is exactly where C++ was in 1995 when Meyers published Effective C++.
The specifics of the argument notwithstanding, the very existence of this discussion validates the need for this book. And it also says some somewhat awkward things about the direction in which Rust is evolving.
And, fine, Rust is more ambitious, just like C++ was. But that too has tradeoffs in language complexity and evolutionary cruft, something that is often cited as an advantage vs. C++. But as we're seeing here, it's not really. It's just that C++ is a few decades farther along on the same curve.
[1] In this case, literally, how to handle a runtime error.
I've asked many people to show me real Rust code that does it differently, and I haven't found any takers.
The confusion here is mostly in terminology and in the "peanut gallery."
This has literally been a solved problem since Rust 1.0. I know because I was there and published a blog post on exactly this topic.
> "the very existence of this discussion validates the need for this book."
Or it could also mean that some folks involved in this discussion haven't yet read the chapter[1] in "The Book" that explains when to panic and when not to[2]?[1] https://doc.rust-lang.org/stable/book/ch09-00-error-handling... [2] https://doc.rust-lang.org/stable/book/ch09-03-to-panic-or-no...