News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My U.S. Arrest Nightmare. by tptacek on Saturday February 25, 2012 @06:15PM (#3634148)
Weird article.

First, so far as I can tell, this guy wasn't arrested. If you're going to have strong opinions on US civil liberties, start by knowing the difference between detention and arrest. In this case, the guy appears to have walked away from the incident with a ticket. He wasn't taken to a station, booked, processed, read his rights, or informed "you're under arrest". Also, in the state of New York, open container is a misdemeanor; in many (maybe most?) states, you can't be "arrested" for a misdemeanor without an outstanding arrest warrant.

Arrest is very bad. It creates a record, it allows the officer to search (thoroughly) your person and immediate presence, and in major metro areas will probably incur the very unpleasant process of being booked (in many cities, this may involve a strip search). Don't get arrested.

Detention is what happens when you're not free to leave but aren't being arrested. You can be cuffed during a detention. Very little cause is required to detain. Detention does not create a record, and (very importantly) does not allow the detaining officer to do much more than frisk for weapons.

In either case, laughing at police officers, while legal, is dumb. Picking a fight with them ("you're giving a bad image of America!") is even dumber. Stanford Prison Experiment aside, whatever the power dynamics may be, you are unlikely to be able to fathom the bullshit city police have to deal with on a daily basis during their shifts. You simply aren't going to be able to take the high ground from them; they don't care. The very fact that you'd consider needling a cop about their behavior is a spectacular luxury, and while I support vigorously everyone's right to avail themselves of that luxury, I'm not particularly impressed by people abusing it.

Finally, a summons for open container is in all likelihood not something that would have any impact on one's immigration status (you can Google this question to see immigration lawyers answering it). "Court summons" sounds scary, but it is exactly the same language used when you get a traffic ticket. Cops: not immigration officials. Happy to clear that up for him.

(Incidentally: in most of the US, you cannot buy alcohol in a pharmacy 24/7 --- although that is, I think, a silly rule).

There are no comments on this comment yet.