News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by MrOwnPut on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @11:13PM (#36335983)
Could you remind us what the "non-lab-leak scenario" is again?

To be clear, is your "likeliness" determined on whether we can find a creature that is more similar to covid than RaTG13 (we haven't) or something else?

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Thursday June 15, 2023 @03:53AM (#36337589)
The non lab leak scenario is just what it historically has been for ~70% of all viruses that we can trace (and probably the remainder as well, but we have no evidence): zoonotic jump.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by Reason077 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @07:11AM (#36338804)
The lab-leak scenario presumes zoonotic jump, too. Just rather than from something in the wild, it's from humanized (ACE2-transgenic) mice, which WIV was known to be using to study SARS-like Coronaviruses.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Thursday June 15, 2023 @07:34AM (#36338994)
SARS-like CoronaViruses != COVID19. All cows are animals. Not all animals are cows.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by Reason077 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @08:26AM (#36339479)
The coronaviruses being studied at WIV included RaTG13, one of the closest relatives (96.1% genomic match) to SARS-CoV-2 ever found in the wild.

But a key difference between SARS-CoV-2 and it's wild relatives is the spike protein with affinity for the ACE2 receptor, so it would have had to have evolved through an intermediate host with a human-like ACE2 receptor. For example, ACE2-transgenic lab mice.

This does not itself rule out the wild-origin theory, but no wild host that could explain the missing link from RaTG13 to SARS-CoV-2 has yet been found.

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Thursday June 15, 2023 @11:04AM (#36341522)
96.1 genomic match is less than the match between a male chimpanzee and a male human.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by MrOwnPut on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#36342501)
There is no closer match to SARS-CoV-2 found in the wild. Pangolins were floated for awhile but I believe the samples were 91%~

If there was GoF being done on the sample (adding of the spike protein to infect humans), that could be the remaining percentage.

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#36343269)
Indeed. So the only reasonable conclusion so far is that we haven't found the reservoir host yet. This may take a while and it may even never happen. If and when we do we will finally be able to make another step in this whole saga.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by MrOwnPut on Thursday June 15, 2023 @12:54PM (#36343360)
You ignored this part of my statement:

> If there was GoF being done on the sample (adding of the spike protein to infect humans), that could be the remaining percentage.

I do not believe one bit the only "reasonable conclusion" is it has to be from nature.

Between the lab sample, the outbreak area, the GoF program being run, the timing, history of lab leaks, and the reaction, a lab leak is very reasonable...

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday June 15, 2023 @02:48PM (#36344909)
I think there may have been a slight misunderstanding here (I'm not particularly familiar with this topic so I may have some concepts mistaken):

> The lab-leak scenario presumes zoonotic jump, too. Just rather than from something in the wild, it's from humanized (ACE2-transgenic) mice

> So the only reasonable conclusion so far is that we haven't found the reservoir host yet.

> I do not believe one bit the only "reasonable conclusion" is it has to be from nature.

If it's discovered that the reservoir host was a mouse in a lab at WIV then "we will finally be able to make another step in this whole saga" in the same way as it being discovered as a wild host. It might be worth reading their comment again.

(Again, I'm not deeply familiar with this topic and may be totally off base; gluing together my personal understanding of the meanings of these words has me arriving at this conclusion. I'm also attempting to clarify someone else's statements so take another grain of salt for that.)

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by MrOwnPut on Thursday June 15, 2023 @03:41PM (#36345448)
Zoonotic would mean it was a natural occurrence. The GoF program of adding the spike protein to attach to the ACE2 receptor and putting it in a mouse would NOT be zoonotic, but lab made. It's a lab mouse. Not a jump, but a deliberate placement in a lab.

Obviously the implications matter whether it occurred in nature or deliberately by man. If it was the latter, then the program that was supposed to prepare against the potential of a natural virus actually made something that may never have happened, and then went on to kill millions.

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Thursday June 15, 2023 @04:46PM (#36346302)
Zoonotic jumps can still happen in a lab. They are simply jumps from one species to another.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday June 15, 2023 @08:52PM (#36349381)
Thanks for the explanations. Admittedly, my introduction to the term “zoonotic” was from playing Plague Inc: Evolved (if one is not familiar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plague_Inc:_Evolved) so you might see where I’m coming from. I do roughly understand this to be the meaning.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:32AM (#36358338)
Interesting. I noticed that one of my kids picked up a lot about how electricity works as well as simple and/or/not/nand gates. But that doesn't mean he knows anything about electricity, merely how the game logic presents it, which is close but not quite how it really works. That doesn't mean he knows nothing either, but it does mean that such knowledge should always be verified with proper sources to ensure you're not accidentally learning something isn't quite true.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:50PM (#36367091)
> verified

Yeah, I have difficulty with this, in particular trusting sources. Wikipedia is almost always correct on a technical level but very information dense (Good Thing! Recently I looked up “captain obvious disambiguation” for a joke and learned the word “lapalissade”) so it sometimes requires a certain mindset to learn from there. Some public school teachers don’t like being questioned(!!) and I think that’s caused me to have an internalized skepticism of academics, ironically despite the likelihood they’re more informed. Rando stranger on the internet can be good source but maybe a bullshitter instead.

On the whole, and especially in particular if one pays attention, people here tend to make “good faith” statements such that a difference of opinion similar to this thread is genuinely informative if one is willing to consider the possibility of any particular thing being true (or not). It helps to understand the difference between statements of fact and opinion. I’ve found it helps also to be open about a lack of knowledge if one is willing to ask questions and “be taught” in a fashion, despite the reputation that such leading statements have.

I try to remind myself that all topics which are able to capture academics’ attention have a lot of depth to them, practically by necessity. My physics teacher in high school was fantastic so I have a solid understanding of the concepts taught in that class -- in my experience, MKS logic has been a helpful mental exercise for understanding any abstraction. But it would still take years of study for me to really understand the things we can’t explain about the physical world. And that’s true of almost anything. Best to keep an open mind.

That turned into a bit more than I expected. I appreciate your comment, if it’s not already obvious! I hope you have a nice day, whenever you read this.

Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by MrOwnPut on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:00PM (#36358880)
Sure, but in this case if it were a zoonotic jump in the lab it would be really really easy for them to have found the animal now wouldn't it?
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by jacquesm on Friday June 16, 2023 @03:53PM (#36362869)
You'd think so. You can draw your own conclusions from there.
Re:First People Sickened by Covid-19 Were Chinese Scientists... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday June 15, 2023 @09:03PM (#36349476)
> putting it in a mouse would NOT be zoonotic

It sounds like the claim is that it’s “from humanized (ACE2-transgenic) mice“. I assume “humanized” is referring to the genome or something else about the genetics but these organisms still shouldn’t be considered humans (or at least this opinion seems reasonable; if it’s factually wrong I’m open to being corrected).

But if it’s “from” non-human “to” human, isn’t that a zoonotic jump, or is there some mistake in this understanding?