I tend toward the latter with respect to Taibbi. I remember him in 2008 and he really strikes me as an angry populist who wants to shake up the system.
Problem is that most revolutions end with “meet the new boss, worse than the old boss.” The fascists are the only alternative to the current system that have funding, organization, discipline, and momentum, so if you overthrow the status quo today you get fascism. There is nothing else waiting in the wings that is ready and willing to step up and fill a power vacuum.
Taibbi also strikes me a Gen-Xer who never let go of edgelording. There was a time when being edgy and provocative was a rebellious act. It isn’t anymore and in fact it may serve power. I’d say the same thing to lefties and others who simply must provoke and edgelord.
I’m not sure about Greenwald but if I had to take a bet I’d say he’s made the full journey from leftist to populist to authoritarian.
That’s a common journey to make. Populism almost always leads to totalitarianism. Whether that takes a “left” or “right” form pretty much depends on which side has more momentum in the culture and can field the most charismatic demagogues. The politics of resentment and grievance just looks for someone to hand out pitchforks.
My reading of both is quite honestly the exact opposite of what you describe, they tend to call out the authoritarianism they see no matter the side. Frankly even Taibbi’s recent foray into Government and Twitter is more an indictment of a government’s overreach into controlling speech which is very authoritarian in action. That series spoke about both Trump and Biden’s administrations attempting to control public discourse. It certainly feels like it was more critical to the Biden admin, and that might help the GOP…but that might be because there was a lot more evidence of it provided to him.
I disagree about a lot of the rest of what you say, but I think you're on point with regard to Taibbi and Greenwald.
I used to identify as left, and would still do that, except that what passed for left-leaning news during COVID became nothing more than propaganda, and left-leaning journalist put their investigative and sceptical credentials to one side.
During COVID, and still perhaps even now, it turns out you can become a member of the far right, just by staying politically still.
There really seem to be some strange shifts recently in the US where the democrats have become quite a bit more hawkish and intolerant of alternative opinions than I have ever seen before in my lifetime.
Honestly, fuck outta here with "alternative opinions" noise.
Could be that. Well demonstrated!
It’s ok to be on a “side” and still be critical of that side. No one would rightly accuse Bill Maher or Jimmy Dore of being conservatives, but they are damn sure critical of certain perspectives as of late of the American left.
I guess if your bubble is pulling it’s identity from the leftist dogma du jour anyone who departs from that orthodoxy would be dismissed as conservative.
Amazing that in 2023, Bernie Sanders and his supporters are now considered conservative.
That really is my point, the center political position is always arbitrary…in general and on any given single political opinion. So most normal people don’t break exactly along the dogmatic lines set by whatever is the governing authority of right and left.
My political opinion is driven above all else by pragmatism that does not break cleanly in right or left or by party. As such where i sit on the political spectrum is always relative to the person evaluating my opinion.
You should probably expand your reading to his articles in Rolling Stone, particularly those from 4-5 years ago. You would not say “ever” if you did that. But…for a writer that admittedly leans left in his politics, he is willing to call out that side when a story leads there.
He is much like Glenn Greenwald in that respect. Both he and Glenn get a lot of hate from folks on the left for daring to stray from the left messaging orthodoxy.