He also says that 60-year-olds are less enthusiastic about learning new tech. Granted I'm even less qualified than him to judge how 60-year-olds think, but the way I see it, if a 60-year-old doesn't want to learn (or feels incapable of doing so efficiently) it's because he stopped learning at some point in his life. It's like exercise, a 70-year old who has gone to the gym two days a week for most of their life will be completely capable of exercising like they always have. If a programmer constantly makes an effort to stay on the cutting edge, they'll have no problems staying there no matter what their age.
Since presumably an engineer(or programmer) who is 27 has 5 years experience there is a world of difference between a 27 year old and a 60 year old. Now compare the 60 year old to a 35 year old. The choice would not be so obvious.
Also, how about energy? Do 60-year olds really have the same energy to keep up with new stuff as a young boy does?
Now an important differentiator may be health. You'll find more 60 yo in bad health than 20 yo, and bad health definitely take a huge toll on efficacy and dynamism.
Similarly, someone with 25 years of experience could really have an advantage over someone with 10 years of experience if their career included working in many different areas. And not all experience is purely technical -- someone who has worked with many different kinds of people and projects for 25 years and has released and supported lots of products might have insights and instincts that a less experienced person might not have.
Very few companies, particularly those in the Valley, seem interested in hiring older workers. Does that not indicate there is little perceived value in years of experience beyond a certain point (say, 5, as the original article suggests)?
Edit: I'll add that I've seen young men (mid 20s) who have the cynicism and bitterness of much older men. That, to me, is sad. It shouldn't be like this.
Or, in other words, companies continue to demonstrate they see little value in experience and the author of the article is bang on when talking about the temporal nature of knowledge capital and the absence of prestige in IT.
Pardon my french, but this is absolute, utter bollocks. I can only assume that this was written my a 27 year old .NET programmer who wants to think that the 60 year olds have nothing on him. Granted, I behaved the same way when I was a 25 year old .NET programmer. I've gotten over it. Such behavior should not be encouraged or glamorized.