Re:Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
by buildbot on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @12:56PM
(#36328842)
Catadioptric does mean exactly that - a combination of mirrors and lenses. In photography, catadioptric lenses are used to make very compact for the focal length telephoto lenses - for example, a 500 mm catadioptric lens with two mirrors and several elements weights nearly an order of magnitude less than a 500mm refractive only design.
I thought it was very interesting and unique, I have no idea what the optical design could look like. Maybe something like the perkins-elmer solid cat design, shrunk down for a long focal length but compact pancake lens.
Re:Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
by kguttag on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:38PM
(#36329512)
Good catch on the "combined with custom catadioptric lenses." Which by definition means a combination of mirrors and refractive optics. But I still don't think they are pancake lenses, but something more akin to what Limbak, which was recently bought by Apple was famous for designing catadioptric optics. Before being bought by Apple, Limbak was best known for their catadioptric design used by Lynx.
Is there a ray diagram the Lynx optics somewhere? I never fully understood how they work (reflection is off the sides of them?). With Apple showing the lens element shapes, is there room for reflecting off from the side?
Re:Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
by drewbeck on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:47PM
(#36329657)
> I’m not the only one to catch this seeming contradiction in messaging.
The contradiction being introducing a new product with a screen? Guess what, watchOS will still suggest you go outside, whether you use a MacBook or a Vision Pro.
This analysis is not particularly sharp.
The vergence issue he is very hot about, but like anything in this space the question is “is this good enough for a lot of people” not “did they solve this to my personal satisfaction (having not used the device)”
Re:Karl Guttag on Apple Vision Pro (Part 1)
by platers on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:55PM
(#36329785)
> There is no vergence accommodation conflict if you have had cataract lens replacement surgery
This is fascinating to me since I am getting vision corrective surgery soon, where could I learn more about this?
There is no vergence accommodation conflict if you have had cataract lens replacement surgery. Tim Cook is 62 so it is possible he can't see it. Even without lens replacement you slowly lose elasticity of your natural lens as you age and need reading glasses to see up close and the effect isn't as big.