News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by coldtea on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @08:27AM (#36324856)
>their intelligence in one area means they’re qualified to make assessments or reach conclusions in fields outside of their own

That's exactly what it means. Or rather, not that they're "qualified (period)" to "make assessments or reach conclusions in fields outside of their own", but "more qualified than someone not as intelligent".

And that's exactly what's the case in a general discussion, when expertise is not a prerequirement. But general discussions are still interesting - and can reach some ideas that actual experts missed or see some systematic expert bias (the way outsiders to a field often can see better than insiders). Of course a lot of it will be garbage still

Of course, if you want only experts on X talking, or people just reciting experts on X, then go to an X conference.

And, last not least, people discussing on an HN thread (or anywhere else) aren't gonna "reach conclusions" in the sense that thet will alter the expert consensus on the field. They aren't going to publish papers or give legal or expert advice on the matter. They're just discussing.

At best, as is their right, they'll follow themselves some misguided medical (or dietary or whatever) idea, or pass it on to someone else (who should, and will, still understand they're not their doctor, just another bro).

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by bla3 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @08:39AM (#36324984)
Have you heard (intelligent!) non-tech people talking about tech? Why would (intelligent!) tech people fare better talking about non-tech?

Domain knowledge is more important than intelligence almost everywhere.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by coldtea on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @08:47AM (#36325083)
>Have you heard (intelligent!) non-tech people talking about tech?

Yes, and a technologist, I assure you that they often make very valid points, can often see things tech people miss, and even when they're wrong, they should have the right to discuss. Unless you want to shut them up, what over purpose does such a protestation serve?

>Domain knowledge is more important than intelligence almost everywhere.

Domain knowledge built by stupid people (or by ideology, or for profit, etc) will be stupid domain knowledge, that intelligence can often see right through. Homeopathy also has its "domain knowledge", for example.

As for domain knowledge built by smart people, it can still have its blind spots, if not for anything else, because of professional bias or some accepted wisdom few dare to contest.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by dagaci on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @09:00AM (#36325221)
The amazing thing about tech-people and especially developer and related is that they are expected to and required to grasp an understanding of other people’s professions in order provide products/services. So I would actually expect tech-people to be able to talk reasonably about non -tech areas and to be quite happy to be corrected when they are way off the track..
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by uoaei on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @09:24AM (#36325546)
Nah, they think they understand, and run with an under-informed opinion on something they have no to little real-world experience with until they've replaced the client's original concerns with something that's oversimplified for the sake of shoving into this or that software architecture pattern.

There are of course trans-disciplinary efforts done right but those take orders of magnitude more time than your typical VCs or zealous ladder-climbers allow in development timelines.

Software developers have been bailed out from having to confront this situation up to now because those who ask for software tend to ask for extremely simple workflow-helper type stuff rather than domain-expert-amplifier type stuff (see: pretty much every SaaS webapp ever). But the low-hanging fruit are getting pretty sparse by this point in the bubble.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by germinalphrase on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:01PM (#36328935)
“those who ask for software tend to ask for extremely simple workflow-helper type stuff rather than domain-expert-amplifier type stuff”

I was a HS English teacher for about ten years before moving into tech, and this reality was a source of frequent frustration with (most/almost all) new ed-tech offerings. There are enough practical constraints on instruction quality that amplification tools would be welcome; however, improving educational quality through improving instrumental performance does not appear to be a notable focus.

FWIW: I believe the low hanging fruit begins with assessment.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by naasking on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @09:27AM (#36325584)
> Have you heard (intelligent!) non-tech people talking about tech? Why would (intelligent!) tech people fare better talking about non-tech?

Becoming an effective programmer trains one's strict logical and causal reasoning skills, since we're always building or debugging large and complex systems from simpler components. We see all kinds of crazy emergent behaviours all of the time, and learn to understand how such things can happen. There are few other disciplines that exercise such skills so intensely (probably math and physics).

I would love to see a study on how effective various experts are at making predictions about something outside of their domain knowledge. I suspect computer scientists and physicists would fare better than most.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by throw4847285 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @10:34AM (#36326653)
I think they would fare far worse. Because of the way that our economy is structured, tech people are overpaid and overvalued, and thus have an inflated sense of their own importance which causes them to overestimate their intelligence.
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by naasking on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:34PM (#36329435)
I don't think we're disagreeing. I was specific to use "computer scientists" rather than "tech people". Lots of tech people are not programmers, which is mainly who I was talking about.
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by throw4847285 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:56PM (#36329818)
We are disagreeing. In my experience computer scientists are the dumbest "tech people" of all.

I'm being facetious here, because I'm on a forum dominated by coders and it's a cheap thrill to troll a little bit. So to restate my opinion with less snark, I don't believe software engineers are any more rational or intelligent than other folks in the tech field. Most of the smartest tech people I've encountered have been product folks, designers, researchers, or engineering managers who don't touch so much code any more.

The reason? All those people acknowledge that all the important problems can only be solved collaboratively. They're also less likely to have come in through the comp sci funnel, and they have a more well rounded set of life experiences. Tunnel vision is exactly the problem being discussed. It's like if you're really good at crossword puzzles and you think that would make you a good English Lit Professor. That's coders thinking that their puzzle solving abilities yield philosophical insights.

All the best software engineers are the ones with an intellectual life beyond coding.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by naasking on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @02:08PM (#36330018)
> So to restate my opinion with less snark, I don't believe software engineers are any more rational or intelligent than other folks in the tech field.

I think "rational" and "intelligent" are imprecise words that have different meanings to different people. I think if we restrict ourselves to the questions like, would a computer scientist or an English Lit professor be able to speak more intelligently about genetics, or psychology, or botany, we have a more well-defined question.

> Tunnel vision is exactly the problem being discussed. It's like if you're really good at crossword puzzles and you think that would make you a good English Lit Professor.

Crossword skills aren't transferrable to English lit, so the analogy fails. Computer science and programming are training in deductive and inductive reasoning, which are general cognitive skills.

It's just self-evident that someone who's experienced and adept at deductive and inductive reasoning would also be adept at solving problems and inferring facts in other domains. They are for sure hampered by a lack of domain knowledge, but my point was that, all else being equal (like their knowledgebase), someone who has this training and experience would simply be more effective at inferring facts about a topic they know little about.

I don't think any point you raised contradicts this argument. Yes, people with more life experience or more varied interests have more knowledge to draw upon from which they can infer tangential facts.

But if said person were also a programmer, they would perform even better at such a challenge. And so, in aggregate, such people would perform better overall at such challenges than other professions.

Edit: there could of course be other mitigating factors that overwhelm this argument, for instance, maybe programmers are less inclined to have varied experiences (hyperfocus on computers, say) and so they just have a smaller knowledgebase from which to argue from, and so they appear less effective at such a challenge. But then not all else is equal.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by throw4847285 on Thursday June 15, 2023 @09:35AM (#36340267)
Thanks for engaging seriously even though I was being snarky. More than I deserve.

For starters, is the kind of problem solving that goes into coding trivially applicable to other problem spaces? That's why I used the crossword metaphor. To me, coding often feels like a puzzle where the reward in terms of serotonin boost far outweighs the effort put in. Now, if we're talking about higher order problems like system design, that I agree is the kind of complex reasoning that can be used in other contexts. However, that kind of thinking is far more similar to problem solving in other fields as compared to coding, and thus is not unique.

And in response to your edit, I do feel that programmers are less inclined to have varied experiences because, as I said earlier, the field has been placed on a pedestal due to our current economy. So even if the reasoning that goes into being a good coder was applicable to other kinds of problems in a unique way, engineers are stunted by their own prestige (and by other psychological factors we don't need to go into here).

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by HFguy on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @11:45AM (#36327691)
My experience is quanty people (I'm one also) have too much confidence in their answers.

To make good predictions, you need to make good estimates AND understand what your confidence in your estimate should be.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by danaris on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @12:16PM (#36328172)
"Sure, lots of people have very rigorous training in critical thinking, research skills, and other important aspects of analysis as part of their scientific, medical, or academic background, but we programmers are the specialest boys who are uniquely able to understand absolutely everything better than anyone else."

C'mon; I'm a programmer too, but this is just rank arrogance.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by naasking on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:31PM (#36329399)
You mean the sentence you completely invented is rank arrogance? I agree.
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by coldtea on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @06:40PM (#36333826)
Of course, a lot of strawman arguments are...
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by HFguy on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @11:39AM (#36327617)
FWIW, I work in finance and often listen to Hackernews discussions on finance and investing. It is often some horrendously bad takes.

I then have the thought, "Am I doing this in areas where I don't have much experience?".

I can only assume there are some pretty stupid thoughts bouncing around my brain.

Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by fortran77 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @08:41AM (#36325013)
This is why "normies" laugh at the discussions on Hacker News, and there are several reddit groups that mock comments made here.
Re:Serotonin booster leads to increased functional brain con... by coldtea on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @08:48AM (#36325091)
A, yes, Reddit, that paragon of expertise, normality, and clear, well articulated thought...