Talking with regular non-techy people who use reddit regularly - nobody outside our bubble even knows about or cares about the whole API fiasco. Most people I've talked with shrug and say they'll just use the official app if that's what it all means. The others asked if they can just pay and use the same 3rd party app in the future.
Reddit has been, and is filled with drama. These public news pieces make the community appear extremely naïve, to a fault. When people hear some of these apps had tens, or hundreds of thousands of users that circumvented ad revenue for reddit - they mostly do not have sympathy for the 3rd party app developers.
Just being realistic. I like reddit as much as the next guy, and agree the leadership is terrible (reddit has a long history of terrible leadership).
If you drive the power users away, nobody is sharing content or engaging in the comments regularly enough for the 9% of casual commenters to stay engaged and they leave - then the 90% goes because there's nothing at all for them to lurk around.
I think they should call it off, and announce that they will go back to the drawing board. Then restart talks with the API users and third party app developers.
What if they reduced the price of Reddit premium to $3/month and made API and third party apps only available for Reddit premium subscribers?
- Reddit would get many more premium subscribers
- App developers would be able to avoid managing subscription fee’s themselves and continue as before
- Users of the official Reddit app would not be affected
- Users of third party apps would have to pay for Reddit Premium - but maybe at a discount