I often hear this on HN and from other techies. I bet you've never ran a serious Facebook or any other Ad campaign and measured effectiveness (in terms of business ROI).
I used to think like you, but they do work (even 0.05% click thru rate is considered effective!) and hence these companies make billions of dollars. Please stop making such ignorant statements. $3 billion revenue is not a small number.
I bet within the next 24 months, Facebook launches their content network ad platform and it will be the first true competitor Google will need to deal with simply because of Facebook's massive scale.
The reason it works for Facebook is because of the amazing (scary) imformatiom they have on their users. But it can be put to good use.
The only "theory" I can think of that would explain Facebook ad revenue as a temporary phenomenon is businesses trying it out or trying to get in early in anticipation of the ad platform improving. I don't buy that though, not at this point. I wish I understand the economics of it better.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=439302
I'm working on a project that has some similarities to what you guys were discussing. Could we connect via email? You can reach me on stefan-at-wantr.com. Cheers.
After recently starting to use them again I'm blown away at how useful and engaging the app is. But the revenue just seems to be hobbling along considering their scale.
They've tried so many models and none really stuck like AdWords for Google. Long term I just don't see the same kind of revenue growth that companies like Google and Amazon have had and continue to have. For any investor in public companies that's kind of terrifying when it's not clear how revenue will grow.