News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Johnny Decimal by drcongo on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @07:47AM (#36308820)
Absolutely no. For all the reasons listed here: https://heyluddite.com/post/4043411544/how-to-name-folders
Re:Johnny Decimal by Mizoguchi on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @08:06AM (#36309020)
There's a lot of nonsense in that article, talking about evolutionary conditioning to alphabetical folder organization. Hundreds of millions of humans can't organize their documents alphabetically because they don't have an alphabet. They don't seem to have a problem with that.
Re:Johnny Decimal by thechao on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @08:33AM (#36309311)
I thought most languages have a collating order — I think even a slightly generous reading is what they mean by 'alphabetical'? Even Chinese (an important edge-case) has the traditional radical-and-stroke ordering mechanism.
Re:Johnny Decimal by f1shy on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @08:56AM (#36309576)
The algorithm at the end is what I go through every single time I search for something. I think this article has a point!
Re:Johnny Decimal by nequo on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:40AM (#36310893)
The algorithm at the end:

  Start -> Open Folder -> End
In reality, natural language uses synonyms that often start with different letters. So without numbers, I still need to scan every directory one by one.

With numbers, I assign categories according to the phase of a process in which the item occurs. For example,

  1 plans
    |- A first draft
    |- B Lisa's notes
    `- C design
  2 analysis
    |- A exploratory
    `- B design implementation
  3 deliverables
    |- A May 2023 report
    |- B June 2023 presentation
    `- C August 2023 report
I can limit my search to folders and items that are in the low/medium/high range, according to what I am looking for. But alphabetically sorted, this directory structure would look much more ad hoc:

  analysis
    |- design implementation
    `- exploratory
  deliverables
    |- August 2023 report
    |- June 2023 presentation
    `- May 2023 report
  plans
    |- Lisa's notes
    |- design
    `- first draft
Re:Johnny Decimal by tomjakubowski on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:10PM (#36313343)
Collation order is not necessarily best for organizing. Many of us think spatially. Having related things near each other can be useful. Same with putting the most commonly used or most important things near the top.