Re:Ask HN: Intel Mac Pro Users with > 192GB of RAM, Views on...
by runjake on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:15AM
(#36310527)
> I'm still hoping they will have a true desktop chip at some time where RAM could be externalized even if it causes a slight performance hit.
I believe it was John Ternus on the WWDC23 episode of The Talk Show that said this isn’t going to happen.They were uncharacteristically firm about this. Same with supporting external GPUs. The indication was this is not going to happen.
And swapping to SSD is pretty stupid - SSDs have finite write lifetimes. Yeah, you can get data center capable SSDs that are over provisioned and cached to the hilt - but at that point RAM would just be cheaper; and still be faster.
I get why Apple is sticking with the tightly coupled RAM on SOC - it's part of the equation that gets them their blistering performance (love my maxed out M1 Max - but kind of nuts 64GB is the most it can have). Some use cases just need more memory - period.
I'm still hoping they will have a true desktop chip at some time where RAM could be externalized even if it causes a slight performance hit. The problem is the number of users who truly need that much RAM is so small I doubt they can justify diverging from their existing architecture that severely.