Re:A New Experiment Casts Doubt on the Leading Theory of the...
by consilient on Monday June 12, 2023 @09:30PM
(#36303953)
> General Relativity doesn’t end just above the atmosphere and quantum mechanics ought to apply to everything, not just experiments.
No one disagrees, but if it were that easy to just jump straight to the final theory we would have done it long ago. For now, effective theories are all we've got.
> Oh sure, we can wave our hands at it and invoke the mass-energy relation from GR, but this doesn’t “pop out” of the Standard Model in any sense.
Yes, it does. You don't need GR for mass-energy equivalence, just special relativity. And the Standard Model is fully special-relativistic.
No one disagrees, but if it were that easy to just jump straight to the final theory we would have done it long ago. For now, effective theories are all we've got.
> Oh sure, we can wave our hands at it and invoke the mass-energy relation from GR, but this doesn’t “pop out” of the Standard Model in any sense.
Yes, it does. You don't need GR for mass-energy equivalence, just special relativity. And the Standard Model is fully special-relativistic.