News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Killing Community by krapp on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:02PM (#36300118)
> Outside of that it's egalitarian and openly accessible to a greater degree than anywhere else on the internet, there's value to that that people miss.

Let's be real - what people miss is being able to act like racist edgelords on the internet without consequence, and they confuse that freedom with something profound, when it's just a deeply ingrained culture of immaturity. But apart from that one aspect, there's nothing to the accessibility of 4chan that isn't available elsewhere, certainly not quality of conversation.

Re:Killing Community by thot_experiment on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:13PM (#36300280)
I don't mean to argue that you should go on 4chan or whatever, but as someone who's been on the site on and off for 15 years now I don't even see the hateful stuff really, it just slides past my brain. I think you're wrong about the level of humanity that exists on 4chan, but if it's not for you that's totally fine. 4chan runs the gamut, that's what I'm trying to get across, the good comes with the bad. There's a cost associated, there are tradeoffs, but to paint it the way you have is not matched to the reality of the situation. There are incredibly kind, thoughtful and well intentioned people on there, and I think the anonymity and lack of consequence is one of the things that enables that. What's more, I have a high degree of confidence they're genuine, there's no point in chasing clout on an anonymous messageboard.
Re:Killing Community by krapp on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:21PM (#36300425)
You misunderstand my point. Kind, considerate, thoughtful and well intentioned people can be found anywhere online. Bringing them up as an example of the unique nature and power of 4chan's community is disingenuous. 4chan is unique in its tolerance for hate speech, but with any other kind of speech, it's no more or less free than elsewhere.
Re:Killing Community by Eisenstein on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:39PM (#36300719)
I personally disagree with the parent but you are misrepresenting their argument. The person you are responding to is referring to the thesis of the article which is 'as a community grows and strangers saturate the regular encounters, so declines the ability of that community to exist in a meaningful way'. They are using 4chan as an example of this thesis in action since the community of 4chan has a self-imposed growth limit due to the nature of its culture (most people couldn't handle it).
Re:Killing Community by thot_experiment on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:31PM (#36300585)
You're right that 4chan has a high level of tolerance for hatespeech, but that's a secondary, derived characteristic from the anonymity and free speech absolutism. There's a level of humanity enabled by that that you don't see elsewhere.
Re:Killing Community by anononaut on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:34PM (#36300632)
I beg to differ. There are genuine, profound, even Socratic conversations which freely happen on various threads that essentially can not occur elsewhere on the clearnet. No idea is invalid, no topic taboo, and each thread and each post must stand alone on their own merit. This is all on top of a large number of deep and wide recurring hobby generals that are both beginner friendly and highly technical. It is more free than any website you can think of off the top of your head.
Re:Killing Community by throwaway122121 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:38AM (#36307359)
As someone who only frequent one of the tamer niche interest board where there are seldom trolls posting slur/gore/porn, my view may be biased, but I would argue that the anonymity that allowed hate speech also enables people to be more candid in their posts and therefore leading to a sense of community.

As long as I don't put anything personally identifiable in each post, the chances of them being linked together to point back to my real identity is miniscule, so I can share stuff I would normally want to keep private.

I have bonded over deeply personal trauma with anons that I will never knowingly meet again but also know they are out there on the same board as me. I've commiserated over health concerns that I wouldn't share on social media in fear of seeming unprofessional nor with friends to avoid making them worry.

Hell, I made a throwaway just to post this since I don't want people to look at my profile and go "that guy is a 4chan user" since that could be an issue professionally, yet nothing I said here is a hate speech. That's an example of how anonymity allows for more honest speech in ways most sites elsewhere don't offer.

Re:Killing Community by commandlinefan on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:32PM (#36300602)
> edgelords

I remember reading newspapers and magazines and watching TV in the 80's and 90's and for the most part, they all seemed to have a unified (left-leaning) perspective on everything. There was the occasional Rush Limbaugh or Bill O'Reilly, but back then, even they tread _very_ carefully - they would deviate maybe a little bit from the maintstream opinion but not much, at least not looking back on it.

I didn't see things the way the news saw them on almost anything. At the time, I thought I must be the only one who disagreed on so many points - after all, if anybody thought like I thought, there would have to be at least some newspaper somewhere that was printing it. But there wasn't.

Then the internet came along, and people could chat and argue with each other without a newspaper or magazine or TV editor getting in between. I found out that there were a lot of people who thought the way I did. A lot of people who disagreed with the dominant news media viewpoint that was 90% identical.

I think there was an initial rush of people who took voicing that disagreement to a bit of an extreme when the internet was new, but that's sort of subsided now - there are full grown adults with college degrees and jobs and mortgages who've been on the internet their whole lives and can't _remember_ when all media was as tightly controlled as Reddit's /r/politics subreddit.

Now the push back is becoming more serious, less "edgy" and more potentially disruptive and even a threat to the people who've made their livings and fortunes censoring debate - it should come as no surprise that there's such a push to get the genie back into the bottle.

Re:Killing Community by com2kid on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:43PM (#36300787)
> I remember reading newspapers and magazines and watching TV in the 80's and 90's and for the most part, they all seemed to have a unified (left-leaning) perspective on everything.

This was the era of satantic panic[1], D&D being controversial due to devil worship, and when democrats and republicans joined hand in hand to try and outlaw vulgarity.

The 80s was absurdly conservative.

A regular talking point on 90s TV newscasts was about if it is ok for a man to kill another man who (romantically) hits on him. That was an actual topic the country was divided over.

1990s America, also not a bastion of radial left thinking.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanic_panic

Re:Killing Community by commandlinefan on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:17PM (#36301281)
If that's the way you remember it (I don't remember it that way, but to each their own) then an unfettered medium like 4chan is still a positive break from a handful of stodgy old ideologues controlling the conversation.

(I even disagree with both the left and the right on some things).

Re:Killing Community by com2kid on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:36PM (#36301531)
This is not a matter of memory, I'm talking about actual court cases, laws passed, and people killed.

https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1268/tipper-gor...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gay_panic_defense#Use_of_the_g...

Then there was the incredible level of controversy over an out of the closet lesbian on nationwide TV!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Puppy_Episode#Reception

Finally, I'll note that Rush Limbaugh was one of the nations most listened to media voices during this time period.

Re:Killing Community by commandlinefan on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:06AM (#36310409)
> https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1268/tipper-gor...

Um... you do know that Tipper Gore was and still is an adamant leftist, right? She's Al Gore's wife.

Re:Killing Community by com2kid on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:06PM (#36313284)
Censorship of music and art was a bipartisan push.

My entire point was that the entire country was more conservative, a point I was demonstrating by showing a time when Democrats and Republicans joining hand in hand to censor music from black musicians. (They also tried to censor violent video games, and the entire internet!)

> Um... you do know that Tipper Gore was and still is an adamant leftist,

Look up https://www.politicalcompass.org/ specifically https://www.politicalcompass.org/analysis2

1 axis for left vs right makes no sense, especially when there are members of both dominant political parties who want to curtail liberties.

Politics as a team sport is stupid, don't vote based on single letter next to someone's name, vote for the individual policies a candidate supports.

Re:Killing Community by wpietri on Monday June 12, 2023 @11:40PM (#36304908)
For sure. This was also the era that labor journalism died and media shifted to being pretty much relentlessly pro-capital.