Re:JPEG XL against AVIF tested on ImageEngine
by cycomanic on Sunday June 11, 2023 @03:47PM
(#36284904)
Agreed, take the Steinway image for example, jpegxl makes a mess of it with the tiny setting, lots of artifacts much detail lost (e.g. the benches on the right, or the piano keys on the left).
Re:JPEG XL against AVIF tested on ImageEngine
by spider-mario on Sunday June 11, 2023 @04:10PM
(#36285111)
On the “Vid Gajsek” image posted elsewhere in the thread, AVIF consistently removes texture in the shadow between the receipt and the cup, even at size “large”. At size “medium”, it does so across the entire cup.
Disclaimer: JPEG XL contributor.
It does but the middle bit looks far better, AV1/tiny is comparable to JXL/large when only looking at middle bit, weirdly enough, everything around is of course worse
I am sure there are examples where JPEG XL outperforms AVIF. But looking through all those images in the test sample I get the impression that AVIF on average in the lowest quality setting is significantly better than JPEG XL.
I agree that the example you presented indeed has the mentioned shadow issue in AVIF.
Re:JPEG XL against AVIF tested on ImageEngine
by JyrkiAlakuijala on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:29AM
(#36290643)
If tiny quality was 1.0 bpp, low quality 1.5 bpp, and medium quality 2.5 bpp and high quality 4.0 bpp, JPEG XL would win in all categories.
In reality cameras produce about 3.5-4.5 bpp, and the internet uses an average of 2 bpp for photographs.
When zooming in 3x I can say that AVIF looks significantly better than JPEGXL in the lower quality settings while being consistently a little bit smaller in filesize. There is better color retention, less noise and looks sharper. At the "tiny" setting the difference is night and day. At the highest setting they are so close enough that I wouldn't say there's a clear winner for me after going through all the images.