Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by dlitz on Sunday February 26, 2012 @03:27AM
(#3635147)
Imagine that we're talking about accounting fraud. The prosecution might be able to prove that the relevant accounting records exist, and have grounds to believe that these records would prove that fraud occurred, but not have the actual contents of the records themselves.
Child pornography is special, because merely having "possession" of certain information is a crime. The law itself is bizarre, so you get bizarre results like this.
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by jasonwocky on Friday February 24, 2012 @11:15AM
(#3629627)
In the abstract, it's possible to have knowledge without having proof.
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by erichocean on Friday February 24, 2012 @06:03PM
(#3631504)
I don't know what "in the abstract" means in this case, but I do know that claiming to "know" something without having actual proof is what's called a conjecture:
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/conjecture
A conjecture is not the same as knowledge, "in the abstract" or otherwise.
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by jasonwocky on Monday March 05, 2012 @05:22PM
(#3668646)
If I saw something with my own eyes, but didn't capture a video recording of it, I could argue that I have knowledge but not proof.
Sorry, you lost me. If the prosecution "already knows", then why does the drive need to be decrypted? It sounds like they already have the evidence.
And if they don't? Well, that's the definition of a "fishing expedition", isn't it?