So if you start with a population of 100,000 employees at entry level, after a few years "most" of them will end up as L7?
That does not make any sense. Senior is the terminal band for "most".
Is this the "if you type randomly type stuff you'll write Shakespeare given enough time" thing?
It might be true (though I doubt it), but the original claim is "by mid 40s". You also need to look at the overall statistics (i.e. percentage of people who made the promotion vs those who haven't), and while the projected ratio based on the previous company growth rates may still support the claim, it's quite clear double digit percentage growth YoY isn't infinitely sustainable...
However... This is starting to change. We now have engineers reporting to higher levels, so basically each manager has an equivalent IC reporting directly to them. In theory this means the numbers are more equivalent.
During calibration the ladder generally isn't consulted but it could be weaponized at any time. It is quite intimidating.
High level ICs have LOTs of weights on the technical directions. They are not replaceable by the managers.
The other thing to watch out for is manager growth over the last 10-15 years was a result of the structural needs of an unprecedented tech bull run. Now that the industry has moved into belt-tightening mode, the heaviest scrutiny is falling on managers. The type of political games a typical 35 year-old EM (5 years coding, 10 years EM) may not be as effective as they were in the previous environment. There are a LOT of EMs getting pipped or knocked back to IC these days, whereas ICs with a bit of product/UX sense, ability to think a bit beyond their silo, and willing to work on "boring" business applications will continue to be highly valued, especially given the amount of dead weight that has found its way in by grinding leetcode.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ff4fRgnuFgQ&t=6585s
<quote> [From 1:49:53] Um, you know, at the beginning of this, we, um, I asked our, our people team, what was the average number of reports that a manager had? And I think it was, it was around three, maybe three to four, but closer to three. I was like, wow, like a manager can, you know, best practices that person can, can manage, you know, seven or eight people. Um, but there was a reason why it was closer to three. It was because we were growing so quickly, right? And when you're hiring so many people so quickly, then that means that you need managers who have capacity to onboard new people. Um, and also if you have a new manager, you may not want to have them have seven direct reports immediately because you want them to ramp up. But the thing is going forward, I don't want us to actually hire that many people that quickly, right? So I actually think we'll just do better work if we have more constraints and we're, um, you know, leaner as an organization. So in a world where we're not adding so many people as quickly, is it as valuable to have a lot of managers who have extra capacity waiting for new people? No, right? So, um, so now we can, we could sort of defragment the organization and get to a place where the average is closer to that seven or eight.
If you make it to my comment, please - do not go into management for the money. If you want to build, then remain an IC. If you want to grow other engineers, further THEIR career, make THEM better - go into management.
The friends of mine who ended up in management for the money and complain about their reports make me so angry.
Please won’t do much, even if I agree. Incentives and all that.
Plenty of people I know do it for other reasons: power, control, purpose, leverage, …
I’ve had too many shitty managers in my career to think I’d put other people through similar experiences. So, my switch into management was motivated by, hopefully, making the experiences on my team positive ones
And sometimes, the people who were asked, due to a combination of stubbornness and a desire not to “sell out”, deny the request for 7-8 years. Eventually, a person might realize that the original requesters may have been correct and that’s how they become a manager.
Or so I’ve heard.
A lot of engineers, of all flavors, are at least partially in the field for the money. Maybe they enjoy their work, maybe they're good at it, but for a lot of people it was more of a plan C or D after the things they really wanted to do turned out to be something they couldn't make money at.
Some of them would rather be authors or musicians, some of them chemists or physicists, a number of them are just waiting to buy a goat farm upstate. If you include them people who would rather be engineering something else, but that something else doesn't pay the bills, it may be a majority of engineers who are in it for the money.
No, it is not. You switch from L6 IC to L1 M (FB/Google scale). Compensation remains exactly the same.
> If not immediately, the cap for ICs is much lower.
This is different from management being a promotion...
Principal engineer at FAANG (L8): likely one of the best engineers in the world.
Engineering director at FAANG (L8): manager who's been there for a while and is good at acquiring more reports.
As a ratio, there are far more eng directors to managers than principal engineers to engineers.
All that said, know what you want in your career. If you love building, build. If you want money, do management.