Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by jules on Friday February 24, 2012 @06:27AM
(#3628834)
If they already know what the contents say then what's the use?
Re:US Appeals Court: Forced Decryption Is Self-Incrimination
by andylei on Friday February 24, 2012 @11:04AM
(#3629573)
this is exactly why they can compel you to testify against yourself. the additional testimony (decrypting your drive) is a "foregone conclusion". this is one of the few exceptions to the fifth amendment.
under some circumstances, they could. the "foregone conclusions" doctrine says that if they know 1) what the contents say, 2) that those contents are incriminating, 3) that you can translate it, and 4) can prove 1-3, then yes, then can compel you to do translate / decrypt.