A king may be a jackbooted oppressor, but he's consistent and more or less unwavering. A mob of peasants protesting the color of the flag is unlikely to get him to change anything. That's the point I was trying to make - Tumblr is the king, and is unlikely to change their tune dramatically, and thus, little risk of this new policy creating ever more new ones.
Is it desirable to have this much power in one place? Maybe. Maybe not. But whether or not this is a desirable or fair system is quite separate from whether or not this system is easily susceptible to slippery slope attacks.
Keep in mind that Tumblr is also not almighty here. Tumblr rules over a kingdom where people can emigrate effortlessly. It may not be democratic, but this presents a natural check on its power.
> "Or I guess I feel that increasing the number of people that have influence on the decision decreases the chances of their being something "arbitrary"."
I think this is where our philosophies diverge. The more cooks in the kitchen, the more arbitrary the meal is going to be, as each one is out to craft their perfect meal.
This might be ok if every person has equal influence on the decision, maybe (cue argument about tyranny of the majority, etc), but in a community-driven voice-driven case, it's less about community consensus and more about which tiny minority can rally the strongest army.
I don't consider myself a creative person, but I can already think of a decent list of things that people consider "dangerous" that I don't (and vice-versa). I mean, pick any random social-political issue and it's not hard to think of things that one side or the other considers offensive or cruel to say. I won't keep going because I think we probably agree a lot here, but I've discussed a few examples in my other replies on this thread.